Need to win can cause PH to embrace Dr M again
Dr Mahathir Mohamad was said to be unwilling to let Dr Wan Azizah Wan Ismail takeover the post of interim prime minister when he resigned.
PETALING JAYA: Two political analysts speculate that Pakatan Harapan (PH) will work with Dr Mahathir Mohamad again if it has to despite recent revelations that paint an unflattering picture of the former prime minister.
Commenting especially on Mahathir’s apparent unwillingness to let his erstwhile deputy, Dr Wan Azizah Wan Ismail, take up the post of interim prime minister after he resigned last year, the analysts said PH would ignore his behaviour for the sake of political expediency.
They were referring to a disclosure made in former attorney-general Tommy Thomas’ memoirs.
According to Thomas, Mahathir submitted his own name for the post of interim prime minister when he learned that his resignation had prompted the Yang di-Pertuan Agong to consider appointing Wan Azizah to the post.
Commenting especially on Mahathir’s apparent unwillingness to let his erstwhile deputy, Dr Wan Azizah Wan Ismail, take up the post of interim prime minister after he resigned last year, the analysts said PH would ignore his behaviour for the sake of political expediency.
They were referring to a disclosure made in former attorney-general Tommy Thomas’ memoirs.
According to Thomas, Mahathir submitted his own name for the post of interim prime minister when he learned that his resignation had prompted the Yang di-Pertuan Agong to consider appointing Wan Azizah to the post.
Kartini Aboo Talib.
Kartini Aboo Talib of Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia and Azmi Hassan, formerly of Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, told FMT they believed PH would not shun Mahathir if he could help it win the next general election.
Kartini acknowledged that PH might see its 22 months of working with Mahathir as a bitter experience, but she said the coalition’s leaders were aware of his ability to attract voters, as seen in the 2018 general election.
Azmi said PH leaders must have known that the King wanted PKR’s Wan Azizah to be the interim prime minister.
Thomas’ revelation would therefore not make any new dent on the relationship between the coalition and Mahathir, he said. “PH and PKR have always been wary of Dr M, but their political tie-up was a way of using one another.”
But he said the PKR grassroots might have been unaware of Mahathir’s disdain of their party and would view the revelation negatively
Kartini acknowledged that PH might see its 22 months of working with Mahathir as a bitter experience, but she said the coalition’s leaders were aware of his ability to attract voters, as seen in the 2018 general election.
Azmi said PH leaders must have known that the King wanted PKR’s Wan Azizah to be the interim prime minister.
Thomas’ revelation would therefore not make any new dent on the relationship between the coalition and Mahathir, he said. “PH and PKR have always been wary of Dr M, but their political tie-up was a way of using one another.”
But he said the PKR grassroots might have been unaware of Mahathir’s disdain of their party and would view the revelation negatively
.
Azmi Hassan.
Azmi also said the general public would now probably speculate that Malaysia’s political situation would be more stable if Wan Azizah had been made interim prime minister.
PKR deputy information chief G Manivannan said Mahathir might have angered voters with his abrupt resignation and PH needed to carry out a careful study before considering any new cooperation with him.
“PKR has been bitten by Mahathir too many times,” he said. “It may not be a good idea to go back to Mahathir again for GE15.
“We have to talk to the grassroots for their views and read comments in social media to know the ground sentiment.”
PKR deputy information chief G Manivannan said Mahathir might have angered voters with his abrupt resignation and PH needed to carry out a careful study before considering any new cooperation with him.
“PKR has been bitten by Mahathir too many times,” he said. “It may not be a good idea to go back to Mahathir again for GE15.
“We have to talk to the grassroots for their views and read comments in social media to know the ground sentiment.”
*********
kt notes:
Reference "Kartini Aboo Talib said the coalition’s leaders were aware of his ability to attract voters, as seen in the 2018 general election", I don't agree as PRIBUMI Bersatu ended up with only 13 seats out of its 52 allocated. It was a monumental disappointment especially for Mahathir himself. In contrast the other major Malay-dominated party PKR did exceedingly well with 47 seats in the GE14 bag.
Mahathir's then resorted to his speciality of welcoming frogs to strengthen PRIBUMI Bersatu. Thus Mahathir's ability has been in enticing frogs rather than voters.
And we noted too that in subsequent by-elections PRIBUMI Bersatu suffered ignominious defeats such as Tanjung Piai.
Thus Mahathir will not bring added value to Pakatan Harapan, though mind you some leaders in DAP and Amanah still believe Mahathir can breach the UMNO Heartland where the votes there will be crucial for majority rule.
The Lims have tasted the forbidden fruit.
ReplyDeleteMayb be willing to sup with the Devil again.
It is wrong to measure Toonsie’s contribution to Harapan’s victory in GE14 from Bersatu’s performance alone, a paltry 13/52.
ReplyDeleteThere was probably some pull as well from the Toonsie effect to convince voters to vote for other Harapan coalition parties (PKR, DAP, Amanah, Warisan) in the other seats.
And remember Bersatu was a first-timer, barely 2 years old and had to compete with UMNO in the Malay heartland, mostly rural UMNO strongholds. So 13/52 was very respectable, Just compare with MCA, 70 year old party won only 1 seat, now THAT was disgraceful...ha ha ha....
Not that I am defending Bersatu or Toonsie ha ha ha again...
Of course Toonsie can bring value to Harapan in GE15, preferably not as a component of Harapan but as a sampan, a tongkat or as a talipon...ha ha ha...
ReplyDeleteHis job is to win 13% of Malay votes, who would otherwise have voted for UMNO, PAS or Bersatu. This 13% support was proven possible, via the Slim by-election where Toonsie-backed independent candidate won 13% of the popular votes.
Perak state by-election, 2020: Slim
Upon the death of the incumbent, Mohd. Khusairi Abdul Talib
Barisan Nasional (UMNO) Mohd Zaidi Aziz 13,060 votes 84.53%
Independent Amir Khusyairi Mohd Tanusi 2,115 votes 13.69%
Independent Santharasekaran a/l Subramaniam 276 votes 1.78%
Total valid votes 15,451
atuk knows mr dickson would never work with him again so why does he still want in? tak malu ke?, the answer is obvious, resident evil wants to cause the breakup of ph, pejuang not being able to register is just a ruse, is pH so hard up and desperate for 5 miserable mps? what Thomas have revealed should act as a wake up call
ReplyDeleteIt boggles the mind to think that there are some in PH who are contemplating wirking with the evil old fool.
ReplyDeleteIf it comes to fruition, PH will in all probability, be wiped out.
I agree with KT's take that the pull factor of the old fool is negligible. Let the old idiot drive along like the deadwood that he is
"boggles the mind"
ReplyDelete!!!???
W/O that mamak's inputs can that hegemony umno + that zombieic faith + the collapsing ketuanan narratives reach their current respective stages of shipwrecking rats?
Think about it.