We don't need the content of the above article in the post for us to be able to discuss the issue - you can read said article yourself.
Yes, the news headline should be sufficient for us to talk about the NEP and its affirmative actions. As we Malaysians know, the 'affirmative actions' of NEP mean special benefits and advantages for Malays.
Robert Kuok believes that affirmative action had/has slowed Malaysia’s progress as a nation.
Mahathir as the über Melayu naturally says affirmative actions are STILL needed.
What is your opinion?
For me, I am NOT against the NEP itself but nonetheless I am very troubled by Mahathir's word 'STILL' as in 'affirmative action STILL needed'.
It's nearly 50 years of NEP's affirmative actions, thus I believe we need to fine-tune it for its true purpose to be realised.
I strongly we have to qualify NEP affirmative action as necessary strictly on a 'NEEDS' basis and not on a skin-colour basis. That way, as an example, poor Indians shall be also entitled to the benefits and advantages of the NEP.
My proposal should still see the majority of beneficiaries being Malays, though scions of Midas-rich Malays should NOT be beneficiaries anymore as daddies and mummies can be their private 'NEP'.
My proposal should still see the majority of beneficiaries being Malays, though scions of Midas-rich Malays should NOT be beneficiaries anymore as daddies and mummies can be their private 'NEP'.
Yes, years ago I wondered where the NEP was going when I saw the daughter of a very wealthy Malay surgeon received a terrifically substantial chunk of scholarship to attend a very prestigious overseas university. Scholarship is one of the affirmative actions of the NEP.
I know the family very well and are good mates with her dad, uncles and cousins. Thus I know her dad could have easily financed her overseas educational needs.
And the thing that riled me most was that she was just an average student to receive such a fantastic scholarship but when I looked around (at that time) I could see and read in newspapers of the significant number of non-Malay students who were bloody brilliant yet could not get one of those scholarships.
I like to see more children of Malay fishermen, Malay labourers and Malay office workers, etc, receive scholarships, thus 'needs' based qualifications are important for the NEP not to be abused by wealthy Malays.
I like to see more children of Malay fishermen, Malay labourers and Malay office workers, etc, receive scholarships, thus 'needs' based qualifications are important for the NEP not to be abused by wealthy Malays.
guess who mostly sell pirate DVDs? |
The other affirmative action of the NEP is the discount for purchases of houses for Malays. Again, why should rich Malays get a 7% discount for the purchase of a house whilst struggling Chinese and Indians have to pay not just the 100% price but also subsidise the 3% given to Malays - now surely you don't think those housing developers were going to bear the loss of those discounts given to Malays?
Thus I disagree with Mahathir that the NEP with its ethnic-based characteristics in all its indiscriminating dispensation (to all Malays regardless of their needs) should STILL continue.