Thursday, March 14, 2019

Suspicious Malaysian dropping of charge against Mbakyu

MM Online - AG refuses Vietnamese woman’s bid to drop Jong-nam murder charge:

SHAH ALAM, March 14 — Vietnamese Doan Thi Huong will remain on trial for the murder of Kim Jong-nam as the attorney general (AG) dismissed her application for the charge to be dropped, the High Court heard today.

Doan 30, is accused in the 2017 killing of Kim Chol or Kim Jong-nam, elder brother of North Korean leader Kim Jong-un.

Deputy public prosecutor Muhamad Iskandar Ahmad told judge Datuk Azmi Ariffin of the AG’s decision on the application filed by the defence on March 11, but did not provide a reason for the refusal.

Doan’s lawyer Hisyam Teh Poh Teik said the defence was disappointed with the decision and said it was unfair to his client.

“The decision is perverse and does not speak well for our criminal justice system. It does not bring confidence to our criminal justice system,” he said in response to the decision.

Teh then requested the court trial to be adjourned, pointing out that Doan has been unwell since her former co-defendant Indonesian Siti Aisyah’s release and was not in a position to testify.

Doan stood accused of poisoning Jong-nam with liquid VX, a banned chemical weapon, at the Kuala Lumpur International Airport in February 2017

jubilant Indons 

The Malaysian government released Indon Siti Aisyah because the Jokowo government had asked for it. The Indons were reported as saying how sweet that successful appeal has been. But many in Malaysia are suspicious of the Malaysian court dropping the charge against Mbakyu.


Prosecutors led the cat out of the bag, telling the court that they had been instructed to withdraw the charge against Siti Aisyah. No reason was given.

Doesn't that smell, nay, stink of political interference.

While the court discharged Siti Aisyah from the case, it rejected her lawyer’s request for a full acquittal, as it said that the trial had already established a prima facie case and she could be recalled if fresh evidence emerged. Obviously the Malaysian court was furious and less than impressed. Refusing a full acquittal was probably its last defiant stand.

Reuters told the world that:

Left to stand trial by herself after Siti Aisyah’s release, Huong was still sobbing as she prepared to take the stand on Monday at the start of her defense. But the court agreed to resume proceedings on Thursday instead, pending a reply from the attorney-general to the request that charges against her also be withdrawn.

“Where is the principle of equality? Both of them were charged on the same evidence, the defense was called on fairly the same grounds,” said Salim Bashir, one of Huong’s lawyers.

“Until today, we do not know what were the exceptional circumstances that were needed for the attorney-general to review the charge against Siti Aisyah. The prosecution never advanced a single ground for the withdrawal.”

Indonesian Law Minister Yasonna H. Laoly said Siti Aisyah’s release, after over two years in prison, was the result of high-level diplomacy by his government, including meetings with Malaysian Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad and the attorney-general.

Yasonna H. Laoly 

“After studying the case thoroughly, we sent letters to the Attorney-General of Malaysia and met with him and Prime Minister Mahathir last August,” Laoly told reporters with Siti Aisyah shortly after landing in Jakarta.

Laoly had written to Malaysia’s attorney-general, laying the blame on North Korea

Since the unexpected Malaysian announcement that charges against Indon Siti Aisyah have been dropped, the Vietnamese government has requested the same 
be done for its national, Doan Thi Huong.

chị dâu 

It's to be noted that the Viet government has NEVER made such an international request before as it expects its nationals to face/answer to the laws of the host nations, but the unexpected relief for the Indonesian woman, following intervention by her government, prompted the Viet government to change its policy.

What's good for the Indon goose should, on the basis of fairness and equal treatment, be also good for the Viet gander, but alas the Malaysian government, probably the world's greatest practitioner of double standards for 62 years, has just shown it's not so.


  1. So now, for court cases involving foreigners, it will be determined by a country's diplomacy?

    Malaysia attitude in this matter must be the murdered victim is a North Korean (brother of Kim Jong Un), so why bother so much. Kim may not even like the murder trial be conducted and if threatened with exposure, might send a nuclear missile onto Malaysia. Might as well forget and close the whole case.

    Vietnam should threaten to declare war on Malaysia, then they can get their national released earlier.

  2. Such extraordinary requests have to be made at the highest levels of government. Head of Government to Head of Government.

    You don't ask, you don't get. It sounds cruel and unfair, but , hey, the world works like that.

    Examples where Donald Trump personally intervened as President to get an American citizen released.

    1. Just like the exchange of the captured prisons between USA & North Korea!

      Anything wrong in the interest of the nation?

      Blue bleeding heart is trying hard to twist a political solution to suit his understanding of fairness in a not so idea political world!

      Eat yr heart out. There will be more to come. Just like what monsie has said, if u don't ask, then DONT expect to get ABYTHING!

      Political favour between nations mah.