Home minister under fire over 'M'sians must know BM' statement
Lawyers for Liberty (LFL) has slammed Home Minister Saifuddin Nasution Ismail for defending an immigration officer who scolded a woman and her daughter for not being able to speak Bahasa Malaysia.
Its director Zaid Malek pointed out there is no requirement for a Malaysian citizen routinely applying for a passport to show proficiency in Bahasa Malaysia.
"To impose such a condition is unlawful, high-handed and will create alarm among the public," he said in a statement today.
Zaid (above, left) also accused the minister of confusing the requirement for citizenship by naturalisation or registration with the requirement for citizenship as a matter of law.
The mother and daughter in the recent incident in Johor, he said, are Malaysians by virtue of operation of law and should not have been subjected to the harassment and ridicule they encountered from the officer.
"Neither the home minister nor any of the enforcement authorities under its purview can simply add stipulations beyond what is required under the law.
"It is imperative that the Home Ministry as an executive body ensure that the law and the Federal Constitution are complied with.
"To that end, there must be an investigation and appropriate action taken against the immigration officer for this unlawful and outrageous conduct; the government must also make sure that all protocols in force in the Immigration Department comply with the law," Zaid said.
Recently, a woman posted on social media alleging that an immigration officer in Johor had scolded her and her daughter for not being able to speak Bahasa Malaysia after responding to his questions in English instead.
Although the posting is no longer available, it was reported that the woman had explained that their poor command of Bahasa Malaysia was due to them residing in Singapore for a long time.
Ti: Check on ‘little Napoleons’
When Saifuddin was asked to comment on the incident two days ago, he told reporters that all Malaysians must know Bahasa Malaysia and that the authorities have a reason to be suspicious when a Malaysian is unable to converse in the national language.
Meanwhile, MCA Senator Ti Lian Ker urged the government to check on “little Napoleons” who abuse their powers.
He also pointed out that there are many elderly Malaysians who are not well-versed in the national language.
Ti: Check on ‘little Napoleons’
When Saifuddin was asked to comment on the incident two days ago, he told reporters that all Malaysians must know Bahasa Malaysia and that the authorities have a reason to be suspicious when a Malaysian is unable to converse in the national language.
Meanwhile, MCA Senator Ti Lian Ker urged the government to check on “little Napoleons” who abuse their powers.
He also pointed out that there are many elderly Malaysians who are not well-versed in the national language.
MCA Senator Ti Lian Ker
“There are also many who are deprived of formal education and do not have the opportunity to learn the national language.
“We should be looking into programmes or policies to help these unfortunate citizens instead of picking on them or penalising them.
“This is not in line with the Madani spirit,” he said in a statement.
“There are also many who are deprived of formal education and do not have the opportunity to learn the national language.
“We should be looking into programmes or policies to help these unfortunate citizens instead of picking on them or penalising them.
“This is not in line with the Madani spirit,” he said in a statement.
Mentality of the ketuanan freaks r beyond normal intelligence.
ReplyDeleteThey breed their own little farts to enlighten themselves!
Government counter officers are quite used to dealing with elderly or barely literate Nons who speak only very basic Bahasa.
ReplyDeleteHowever, obviously well-educated Nons who can't speak Bahasa are an embarrassment.
If you choose to reside in Singapore and use their language instead of trying to speak to the Malays in Singapore that clearly shows you're not a proud Malaysian. Even those who did not get formal education are still able to speak pasar malay nonchalantly. Enough with vernacular education.
ReplyDeleteMfering melayu palsu, Red dot has 4 official national languages.
DeleteBesides what language been used for communication is UO to the communicating users.
Keep yr terlampau ketuanan fart to yr self!