Sunday, July 24, 2011

RCI report on Teoh Beng Hock - the Dark Interregnum

Every violation of truth is not only a sort of suicide in the liar, but is a stab at the health of human society - Ralph Waldo Emerson

Lies, lies, and damn lies ... which have been why I posted in The missing public trust that no one in Malaysia (other than the most hard core & faithful UMNO supporters) would trust in and rely on the objectivity of public institutions or ministers.

We see more of this in The Malaysian Insider’s
Bar Council says MACC responsible for Teoh’s death.

Far more important, and totally damning for Minister Nazri and the cabinet, has been the Bar Council President, Lim Chee Wee’s repudiations of Minister Nazri’s untrue assertions. TMI reported:

Lim also rejected the notion that Teoh’s “weak character” had led him to suicide, as described by Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department Datuk Seri Mohamed Nazri Aziz when he announced the release of the RCI report.

He pointed out that forensic psychiatrist Professor Paul Mullen had not testified that Teoh had a “weak character” and had not concluded that Teoh had committed suicide.

It’s just unbelievable that Minister Nazri had the brazen nerve in believing he could get away with putting words in Professor Paul Mullen’s mouth. Obviously Nazri, knowing there is no credible source on the authority’s side, had hoped to hitch a stowaway ride on a credible source.

But then, how do we explain the following extract of TMI’s report?

On the other findings in the RCI report, Lim said the council had concurred with the royal panel that Teoh had been subjected to “aggressive relentless oppressive and unscrupulous interrogation” and that most of the MACC officers involved in the case were not credible as they “had the inevitable habit of lying”

Lim said the council also agreed that the massive operation launched by the Selangor MACC at the time had been based on a mere belief without proper ground work or verification. The then-Selangor MACC deputy director Hishammuddin Hashim, he said, had been accurately described in the RCI report as “arrogant, given to falsehoods, untruthful and uncompromising” and “just too stubborn to retreat from his mistake in mounting such a massive operation”.

We know the answer would be found somewhere in the period between the RCI's submission of its report to the Agong (and thus, effectively the cabinet) and its public release, nearly 3 weeks of unaccountable 'blackout', not unlike a crucial moment at one of the polling station in interior Sarawak in the State's last election, when the creativity of dark forces would be at its zenith wakakaka.

The Bar Council’s disagreement has been strictly with Minister Nazri’s spin (his attempt to put words in the mouth of credible expert like Prof Mullen). Notwithstanding the implausible finding of 'suicide', now totally demolished by the Bar Council's repudiation of Nazri's pathetic and shameful attempt to 'justify' the finding, there is enough in the RCI's report to show some genuine investigation. But ...

... BUT there is now an increasing* suspicion that in the silent interregnum, there has been some disingenuous ‘creativity’.

* 'increasing' means the suspicion was already there way before the public release of the RCI report, but since then, has escalated to humongous dimensions

If so, then it supports the rakyat's perception that in Boleh Land court cases, coronial inquests, police reports, pathological reports and hospital medical checks etc must always support the side of the UMNO-led government and its pro-UMNO public institutions. How it would or could be achieved is irrelevant. It could be a voluntarily case of what Sasterawan Negara (National Laureate) Samad Said termed 'charma' (cari makan), or it could be involuntary.

We also know why, as reported in TMI, that the
Teoh family boycotted RCI when, aside from the RCI chairperson being (unusually) a sitting Federal Court judge, the RCI insisted on continuing the inquiry despite a proposed judicial review over the appointment of deputy public prosecutors DPPs (from the AG's Office) as conducting officers.

And the ultimate insult to the Teoh family’s wish for at least some (whom they see as) impartial and outstanding citizens sitting as RCI members was when Najib and his cabinet rejected what was a fair and reasonable request.

I wrote on that in one of my earlier (February) posts
RCI = Regrettable Conflict of Interest?

The Teoh family after consulting 126 NGOs had earlier proposed (a) former national police chief Tun Hanif Omar, (b) former Bar Council president Datuk Ambiga Sreenevasan, (c) former Court of Appeal judge NH Chan, and (d) former Deputy Prime Minister Tun Musa Hitam. But Najib has failed to appoint even one of them to the RCI. Why?

Surely these four are Malaysian luminaries with impeccable credentials and reputations of integrity, with even an UMNO man in Musa Hitam. The only person, also of exceptional integrity and courage, former Justice NH Chan, may perhaps be seen by the Najib administration as being anti-government. If that is the case, kaytee suggests he be replaced by former Justice Gopal Sri Ram, who is also retired.

But in refusing such a request for outstanding citizens, including even UMNO's Musa Hitam to sit on the RCI, Najib and his cabinet had actually revealed their true colours, their intention and what they had already decided on the outcome, thus the Teoh family's correct boycotting of the RCI at least didn't confer on the inquiry its most desired and most important vestige of credibility.

As Sir Humphrey Appleby advised: 'Minister, two basic rules of government: Never look into anything you don’t have to. And never set up an enquiry unless you know in advance what its findings will be.' And so it was.


  1. this the same govt that bombed out a mongolian girl.
    this is the same governemt that TBH perished under.
    and this is ecactly teh same government that sarbarni mysteriously jumped to his death for no reason.

  2. All roads lead back to Najib.

    MACC itself does not actually have the clout to subvert the RCI's report.

    Najib must go...

  3. all that has been said, shows their fear of najib, a guy you cannot twist and shit upon like Pak Dol. Sorry mate, you have to live with it. Born losers using any tool to discredit najib. hahahahaaa.....

  4. Good blog checkout my blog.

  5. anon 1.25pm

    might is right?

    an eye for an eye is what you endorsed?

  6. Anonymous 1.25 pm
    You may want to spend a bit of time researching the UMNO-based blog postings in the last 2 weeks.
    Najib is in deep trouble from within his party....the knives are out, since they sense he has now been badly mauled.

    Dolah could walk away into retirement with his young(ish) such exit for Najib. The Mongolian ghost eagerly awaits his dethronement...

  7. We all know that our Umno GOM is the master of all fix its,courtesy of Dr Mahathir.As this pariah Umno's authoritarian GOM has control over our public institutions there is nothing we can do except to expect that these individuals take resposibility for their behaviour.

    Murder or forced suicide as the corrupted RCI calls it is no excuse.The minimun that these culprits should be charge is voluntary manslaughter.We have to accept it.There is nothing that anybody can do as the PDRM is under the thumb of the Umno GOM.Let these criminals pay for their crimes and let TBH's family have a closure of this tragedy.

  8. this is the same sitting judge that gave you humpty dumpty decisions on Perak and Anwar. so, can you blame the people for the cynicism?

    IRRELEVANT IRRELEVANT IRRELEVANT, did you remember? One perished, another step into the shoes. there's no shortage of low-lifes in town.

    Sad sad day for Malaysians.