Guardian:
‘Beyond comprehension’ for Israel to claim there is no starvation crisis in Gaza, Australia PM says
Greens mount parliamentary push for Labor to level further sanctions on members of Israeli government
Josh Butler and Tom McIlroy
Tue 29 Jul 2025 17.04 AEST
The Australian prime minister, Anthony Albanese, has raised concerns about Israel restricting journalists from visiting Gaza as the ongoing humanitarian crisis continues to escalate. Photograph: Mick Tsikas/AAP
Anthony Albanese says it is “beyond comprehension” that Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, and the country’s embassy in Canberra have claimed there is no starvation crisis in Gaza.
Australia’s prime minister also raised concerns about Israel restricting journalists from visiting the war-torn Palestinian territory. It comes as the Greens party mounts a parliamentary push for the government to level further sanctions on members of the Israeli government.
Speaking in response to a question during Labor’s caucus meeting from MP Ed Husic about Australia potentially recognising a Palestinian state, Albanese criticised the Israeli government’s claims. He referred to comments from Netanyahu, reported overseas, as well as reports from Australian media outlets about comments from the deputy Israeli ambassador, Amir Meron.
Meron reportedly told journalists in a briefing on Monday, to which Guardian Australia was not invited, that Israel believed photos of starving Palestinians were “false pictures” from a “false campaign that is being [led] by Hamas”.
“We don’t recognise any famine or any starvation in the Gaza Strip,” Meron reportedly said.
In comments to a meeting of the Labor caucus on Tuesday, Albanese referred to such claims as “beyond comprehension”.
Albanese also told the party room that while there should be a “caveat” on any health information shared by Hamas, he noted that Israel had blocked many journalists from entering Gaza to report first-hand on the conflict and the humanitarian situation on the ground.
The Israeli embassy in Canberra was contacted for comment.
Responding to Husic’s question about a timeline for Palestinian statehood, Albanese did not give a set timeframe for when Australia might move. However Guardian Australia understands the prime minister referred to the Nelson Mandela quote that “it always seems impossible until it’s done” – taken by some in the meeting as a reference to Albanese’s belief that pre-conditions for recognising a Palestinian state could be met in the near future.
Albanese’s comments came days after he accused Israel of breaching international law in restricting aid deliveries into Gaza.
“Quite clearly it is a breach of international law to stop food being delivered which was a decision that Israel made in March,” Albanese told the ABC’s Insiders program on Sunday.
Dozens of Palestinians have died of hunger in recent weeks in a crisis attributed by the UN and other humanitarian organisations to Israel’s blockade of almost all aid into the territory.
Asked about starvation issues in a Tuesday press conference, opposition leader Sussan Ley stopped short of criticising Israel. Asked directly if people in Gaza are facing starvation, Ley repeatedly said only that it was a “complex situation”.
“There are reports of Hamas interrupting the flow of aid and carrying on its atrocious activities at this time,” she said. “Now, if we want the war to end, and we all do, we know the simplest, quickest way is for Hamas to surrender and release the hostages.”
Independent senator David Pocock criticised Labor for “just saying harsher and harsher things”. He told ABC TV tough sanctions should be applied against Netanyahu.
“The time for just words is over. We’ve even got President Trump now saying that clearly starvation is happening. It’s time to start with more targeted sanctions, starting with Prime Minister Netanyahu, ratcheting them up.”
Two leading human rights organisations based in Israel, B’Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights, said on Monday that Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza.skip past newsletter promotion
The US president, Donald Trump, told Israel to allow “every ounce of food” into Gaza, saying there is “real starvation” in the region.
Trump, in a press conference with the British prime minister, Keir Starmer, said: “Those children look very hungry … That’s real starvation; I see it and you can’t fake that.”
Coalition senator James Paterson told Sky News he was concerned about the “very dire” humanitarian situation in Gaza, and that Israel had “a responsibility to ensure that the civilian population is fed”.
“It is doing harm, in my judgment, to Israel’s international standing that they so far, in recent months, have not been able to do that,” Paterson said.
“I welcome the changes in policy and approach that have occurred over the last couple of days of facilitating the flow of further aid and further food into Gaza.”
The Greens on Tuesday called for Australia to implement additional sanctions on Israel, matching the measures applied over Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The plan for so-called autonomous sanctions would target members of the Netanyahu government and other key decision-makers, limiting their travel and use of financial assets.
Australia has sanctioned about 1,400 people in Russia over the war in Ukraine, but only a small number related to the war in Gaza. In June, Australia joined countries including the UK and New Zealand to sanction far-right Israeli government ministers Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich for inciting violence against Palestinians in the West Bank.
The Greens foreign affairs spokesperson, David Shoebridge, said sanctions should also be imposed to stop the export of goods and materials from Australia to Israel, including arms, and called for the cancellation of contracts with Israeli companies.
The party is critical of the Albanese government for not blocking exports of key parts for fighter jets, manufactured in Australia and assembled in Israel.
“If applied to Israel, [sanctions] would mean no more F35 parts, no more drone shields, no more aluminium and steel that we know feeds the armaments industry and allows the Israeli Defense Force to engage in those repeated breaches of international law in the horror show in Gaza,” Shoebridge said at a Tuesday press conference.
Anthony Albanese says it is “beyond comprehension” that Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, and the country’s embassy in Canberra have claimed there is no starvation crisis in Gaza.
Australia’s prime minister also raised concerns about Israel restricting journalists from visiting the war-torn Palestinian territory. It comes as the Greens party mounts a parliamentary push for the government to level further sanctions on members of the Israeli government.
Speaking in response to a question during Labor’s caucus meeting from MP Ed Husic about Australia potentially recognising a Palestinian state, Albanese criticised the Israeli government’s claims. He referred to comments from Netanyahu, reported overseas, as well as reports from Australian media outlets about comments from the deputy Israeli ambassador, Amir Meron.
Meron reportedly told journalists in a briefing on Monday, to which Guardian Australia was not invited, that Israel believed photos of starving Palestinians were “false pictures” from a “false campaign that is being [led] by Hamas”.
“We don’t recognise any famine or any starvation in the Gaza Strip,” Meron reportedly said.
In comments to a meeting of the Labor caucus on Tuesday, Albanese referred to such claims as “beyond comprehension”.
Albanese also told the party room that while there should be a “caveat” on any health information shared by Hamas, he noted that Israel had blocked many journalists from entering Gaza to report first-hand on the conflict and the humanitarian situation on the ground.
The Israeli embassy in Canberra was contacted for comment.
Responding to Husic’s question about a timeline for Palestinian statehood, Albanese did not give a set timeframe for when Australia might move. However Guardian Australia understands the prime minister referred to the Nelson Mandela quote that “it always seems impossible until it’s done” – taken by some in the meeting as a reference to Albanese’s belief that pre-conditions for recognising a Palestinian state could be met in the near future.
Albanese’s comments came days after he accused Israel of breaching international law in restricting aid deliveries into Gaza.
“Quite clearly it is a breach of international law to stop food being delivered which was a decision that Israel made in March,” Albanese told the ABC’s Insiders program on Sunday.
Dozens of Palestinians have died of hunger in recent weeks in a crisis attributed by the UN and other humanitarian organisations to Israel’s blockade of almost all aid into the territory.
Asked about starvation issues in a Tuesday press conference, opposition leader Sussan Ley stopped short of criticising Israel. Asked directly if people in Gaza are facing starvation, Ley repeatedly said only that it was a “complex situation”.
“There are reports of Hamas interrupting the flow of aid and carrying on its atrocious activities at this time,” she said. “Now, if we want the war to end, and we all do, we know the simplest, quickest way is for Hamas to surrender and release the hostages.”
Independent senator David Pocock criticised Labor for “just saying harsher and harsher things”. He told ABC TV tough sanctions should be applied against Netanyahu.
“The time for just words is over. We’ve even got President Trump now saying that clearly starvation is happening. It’s time to start with more targeted sanctions, starting with Prime Minister Netanyahu, ratcheting them up.”
Two leading human rights organisations based in Israel, B’Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights, said on Monday that Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza.skip past newsletter promotion
The US president, Donald Trump, told Israel to allow “every ounce of food” into Gaza, saying there is “real starvation” in the region.
Trump, in a press conference with the British prime minister, Keir Starmer, said: “Those children look very hungry … That’s real starvation; I see it and you can’t fake that.”
Coalition senator James Paterson told Sky News he was concerned about the “very dire” humanitarian situation in Gaza, and that Israel had “a responsibility to ensure that the civilian population is fed”.
“It is doing harm, in my judgment, to Israel’s international standing that they so far, in recent months, have not been able to do that,” Paterson said.
“I welcome the changes in policy and approach that have occurred over the last couple of days of facilitating the flow of further aid and further food into Gaza.”
The Greens on Tuesday called for Australia to implement additional sanctions on Israel, matching the measures applied over Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The plan for so-called autonomous sanctions would target members of the Netanyahu government and other key decision-makers, limiting their travel and use of financial assets.
Australia has sanctioned about 1,400 people in Russia over the war in Ukraine, but only a small number related to the war in Gaza. In June, Australia joined countries including the UK and New Zealand to sanction far-right Israeli government ministers Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich for inciting violence against Palestinians in the West Bank.
The Greens foreign affairs spokesperson, David Shoebridge, said sanctions should also be imposed to stop the export of goods and materials from Australia to Israel, including arms, and called for the cancellation of contracts with Israeli companies.
The party is critical of the Albanese government for not blocking exports of key parts for fighter jets, manufactured in Australia and assembled in Israel.
“If applied to Israel, [sanctions] would mean no more F35 parts, no more drone shields, no more aluminium and steel that we know feeds the armaments industry and allows the Israeli Defense Force to engage in those repeated breaches of international law in the horror show in Gaza,” Shoebridge said at a Tuesday press conference.
Yawn....Beyond Belief that Hamas Oct 7 Stupidity and Release of ALL Isreal Hostages is NEVER PART OF NARRATIVE..... TRUTH OF THE MATTER ....THERE IS WAR THERE....LIKE RUSSIA - UKRAINE.....LIKE CONGO CHRISTAINS MASSACRED....LIKE SYRIAN DRUZE, ALAHWHITES MASSACRERS....ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS FROM ISLAMIST COUNTRY CONDEMING MALAYSIAL TO PARIAH STATE.....NO WORRIES....NIMBY!! .....TALKING TOUGH...BUT ARE STUPID WHEN ISREAL IS INVOLVED!!
ReplyDelete