Friday, April 18, 2025

Boeing jet departs China delivery plant as US tariffs bite


FMT:

Boeing jet departs China delivery plant as US tariffs bite


Flight tracking data shows the jet that arrived at a Shanghai plant last month appears to return to Seattle


Uncertainty over deliveries added to Boeing’s setbacks, as it struggled with recovery after a challenging year of strikes and supply chain issues. (EPA Images pic)


SHANGHAI: A Boeing jet that arrived at a completion plant near Shanghai last month appeared to be returning to Seattle, flight tracking data showed on Friday, in a sign that at least one Chinese airline could be halting deliveries due to U.S. tariffs.



The US planemaker was reported earlier this week to face a Chinese ban on its imports, part of an escalating confrontation over US President Donald Trump’s “reciprocal” global tariffs, though industry sources said the status of rules remained unclear.


In a sign that Boeing was preparing for normal business just weeks before Trump announced tariffs on April 2, tracking data showed at least four new 737 MAX planes sitting at a completion and delivery centre in Zhoushan, where Boeing installs interiors and paints liveries before handing aircraft to customers in China.

Three arrived from Boeing in Seattle in March and one arrived last week, according to Flightradar24.


On Friday morning one of those jets departed Zhoushan for Guam – one of the stops such flights make as they cross the Pacific Ocean – indicating it was making the return journey, tracking data shows.

The plane involved carried a Shandong Airlines livery as of February 2024, according to a photo available through Flightradar24. Air China owns a controlling stake in that carrier. Air China did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Aviation publication The Air Current on Thursday reported that the first of three of the four recently arrived planes had been tagged to be recalled to the US without a handover.

Boeing declined to comment.

The planemaker opened the plant southeast of Shanghai in 2018 under the shadow of a previous round of trade tensions between Washington and Beijing during Trump’s first presidency.

Although Boeing has not followed Airbus in assembling full airplanes in China, analysts said the aim was to build a lead in one of the world’s largest air travel markets.

Airline and aerospace industry sources said there was no confirmation of a formal ban on Boeing deliveries, reported earlier this week by Bloomberg News, but that the imposition of tariffs would effectively block imports for the time being.

Beijing has also asked that Chinese carriers halt purchases of aircraft-related equipment and parts from US companies, the Bloomberg report said.


A senior industry source said Boeing and suppliers are planning on the basis that it would not be delivering planes to China for the time being.

However, two US industry sources said they were given no clear instructions not to ship parts to China. A separate source, who runs a maintenance and repair shop for aircraft in China, said they have not had any issues importing American parts.

China’s foreign ministry declined to comment.

Asked by media about the reported ban, a spokesperson said: “I’d refer you to competent authorities”.

Delivery limbo

For aerospace, Zhoushan is the latest staging post in a growing US-led trade war. Planemakers, airlines and suppliers are reviewing contracts after Reuters reported that US supplier Howmet Aerospace had ignited a debate over the cost of tariffs by declaring a “force majeure event”.

Confusion over changing tariffs could leave many aircraft deliveries in limbo, with some airline CEOs saying they would defer delivery of planes rather than pay duties.

Boeing historically sent a quarter of its deliveries to China but the proportion has been falling following earlier trade tensions, a 737 MAX safety crisis and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Analysts said a short-term halt in deliveries to China would not have an immediate major impact on Boeing, since it could serve other airlines and Airbus lacks spare capacity.

In the longer term, China remains a strategic market. Boeing says China will more than double its fleet by 2043, with the country set to overtake the US in terms of air traffic.

Uncertainty over deliveries marks yet another setback for Boeing, which is navigating a slow recovery following a challenging year marked by a labour strike, enhanced regulatory scrutiny and persistent supply chain disruptions.

Boeing data shows 130 unfilled orders for China-based airlines and lessors, including 96 of the 737 MAX. Industry sources say a significant portion of the more than 760 unfilled orders for which Boeing has yet to name a buyer are for China.

Chinese airlines lease 55% of their jets and it is “highly probable” they will try to extend any expiring leases for the time being, IBA Chief Economist Stuart Hatcher said.


After China flags, PAS weaponises pig farms ahead of the next week’s Ayer Kuning by-election





After China flags, PAS weaponises pig farms ahead of the next week’s Ayer Kuning by-election






MADANI government backers have hit out at Perikatan Nasional (PN) for resorting to play the ‘pig card’ in its Ayer Kuning by-election campaign when PAS which is the coalition’s biggest ally has previously ‘bragged’ that it has no issue with pig rearing even in Kelantan which is under its rule.


This came about after PAS vice-president Datuk Idris Ahmad raised concerns about an alleged excess of pig farms in Malay-majority areas within the Ayer Kuning state constituency.


“According to information on the Perak Veterinary Department’s website, there are 30 licensed pig farms in the Batang Padang and Mualim districts alone,” the Bagan Serai MP told a media conference at PN’s operations centre in Bidor, Perak, yesterday (April 17).

However, Idris alleged that PN’s field observations found “numerous” legal and illegal pig farms in Malay-majority areas such as Kampung Tanjung Keramat which has a 98.9% Muslim population.



“Residents in these areas have to put up with foul odours daily while also facing the constant threat of infectious diseases due to waste pollution caused by these pig farms,” he added.


Idris’ statement prompted a pro-Madani netizen to share news reports of PAS openly declared that it has no qualms with non-Muslims operating pig farms.



This led to BULETIN RMS (@RajaMohdShahrim) asking why PAS did not just shut down the pig farms when it governed the state.


Although a pro-PN supporter corrected BULETIN RMS with a Bernama report dated Nov 24, 2021 that a total of 34 pig farms had been closed in Perak for not meeting licensing requirements, the former responded with another news report that no closure took place.

Instead, the Perak Veterinary Services Department (JPV) had only ordered pig farm operators in Malim Nawar to improve their operations so as to prevent odour pollution in the surrounding area.





In fact, another commenter sided BULETIN RMS that even during PN’s 33-month administration, both the former Perak menteri besar Datuk Seri Ahmad Faizal Azumu (currently Bersatu vice-president) and the PAS Perak state commissioner Razman Zakaria had never made a fuss about pig farms.

This led to accusations that the pig farm issue is raised to canvass for votes from Ayer Kuning’s 31,940 eligible voters, of whom the Malays made up 55.97%, Chinese (22.9%), Indians (14.38%) and others (7.5%).



At the end of the day, a commenter summed up PAS’ tendency to ride on anything that it deems capable of enabling the Islamist party to obtain or hold on to power with a meme. – April 18, 2025





Court orders preacher to pay KJ RM2.5mil in damages


FMT:

Court orders preacher to pay KJ RM2.5mil in damages


Ho Kit Yen

Khairy Jamaluddin sued preacher Rasyiq Alwi in 2022 for alleging that the former health minister had ‘lied’ about his vaccination status


The hearing previously proceeded without the preacher being present although ex-health minister Khairy Jamaluddin’s lawyers had notified him of the hearing dates. (Bernama pic)


KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court here has ordered a preacher to pay a total of RM2.5 million in damages to Khairy Jamaluddin over defamatory statements on the former health minister’s vaccination status.

Khairy filed a lawsuit against Rasyiq Alwi in 2022 for alleging that he had “lied” about his vaccination status.


Justice Raja Ahmad Mohzanuddin Shah Raja Mohzan held that Rasyiq’s remarks against Khairy were false and had tarnished the former minister’s reputation.

“The defendant (Rasyiq) also blatantly disregarded the court’s courtesy by attempting to delay the trial and today’s decision by filing an application to reopen the case.


“The court will not tolerate his attempt to scuttle the case,” he added.

The hearing had proceeded without Rasyiq being present although Khairy’s lawyers had notified the preacher of the hearing dates.


Anwar slams US commentator as ‘arrogant, ignorant’ for mocking Malaysia's economy





Anwar slams US commentator as ‘arrogant, ignorant’ for mocking Malaysia's economy



Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim speaks to reporters during the Ministry of Finance's Hari Raya celebration in Putrajaya today. — Picture by Yusof Mat Isa

Friday, 18 Apr 2025 5:40 PM MYT


PUTRAJAYA, April 18 — Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim today slammed far-right US commentator Bill O’Reilly as “arrogant” and “caught in imperialist attitude” for mocking the economic capacity of Malaysia following Chinese President Xi Jinping’s recent visit.

Responding to the former Fox News host’s comments, Anwar said that O’Reilly had demonstrated a thinking process shaped by ignorance and an imperialist attitude.


“This (comment) is a reflection of an extreme and arrogant nature of some people who are actually ignorant and think that only their country is the mightiest,” he told reporters after attending an Aidilfitri celebration hosted by the Finance Ministry here.

“He absolutely has no knowledge of Asia, Asean and the recent developments.


”In social sciences, we call this trapped thinking led on by an imperialist attitude, which leads to attitudes such as xenophobia, Islamophobia and discrimination against other religions,” he added.



O’Reilly had reportedly derided Xi’s visit to Malaysia following US President Donald Trump’s tariff blitz, and belittled Malaysians as people who “have no money at all” to buy Chinese goods.

“The Malays aren’t going to buy your stuff, they don’t have any money!”, he said in a video that has widely circulated online.


Xi visited Malaysia this week for the first time in 12 years, as part of his Southeast Asia tour, to bolster economic cooperation with the region amid an escalating trade war between China and the US.

His three-day state visit involved the signing of 31 memoranda of understanding (MoUs) covering cooperation in various sectors, ranging from emerging techs and satellite navigation systems, between both countries.

Malaysia currently faces a 24 per cent tariff for all goods entering the United States, while China is subjected to a 245 per cent tariff.

While China has retaliated by imposing a 125 per cent tariff for US goods entering the country, Malaysia has ruled out doing so.

Investment, Trade and Industry Minister Tengku Datuk Seri Zafrul Aziz and Finance Minister II Datuk Seri Amir Hamzah Azizan are expected to meet US officials in Washington by end of April to deliberate on the matter.

Malaysia welcomes US tariff cut on palm oil, eyes RM21b in exports but warns against overreliance on single market





Malaysia welcomes US tariff cut on palm oil, eyes RM21b in exports but warns against overreliance on single market



Approximately 450,000 smallholders are the backbone of the Malaysian palm oil sector. — Picture by Ahmad Zamzahuri

Friday, 18 Apr 2025 3:01 PM MYT



KUALA LUMPUR, April 18 — Malaysia remains optimistic and stands ready to adjust its palm oil export strategy in response to new tariff measures imposed by the United States (US), said Plantation and Commodities Minister Datuk Seri Johari Abdul Ghani.

He noted that Malaysia’s export tariff to the US is now set at 10 per cent for a 90-day pause period, aligning with the rate imposed on Indonesia, a significant reduction from the previous rates of 24 per cent for Malaysia and 32 per cent for Indonesia.


“The US market is not our only focus. What’s important is that we continue to produce high-quality products. International companies such as Nestlé are not merely seeking low prices, they prioritise quality to safeguard their brand reputation,” he told the media after the memorandum of understanding signing ceremony between Malaysian Sustainable Palm Oil (MSPO) and Nestlé Malaysia here, today.

Johari also disclosed that Malaysia’s exports to the US are projected to reach RM21 billion this year, with palm oil products contributing RM4.9 billion.


He added that rubber exports, including gloves, account for RM8.2 billion, furniture RM6.5 billion, and cocoa-based products such as cocoa butter RM1.6 billion.


“We must remember that the US is not Malaysia’s only market, and we cannot rely solely on one destination. Any excess export capacity can be redirected to other markets.”

As such, Johari urged Malaysian exporters to place greater emphasis on producing high-quality products at competitive prices to strengthen their global market position.


In a related development, the minister also highlighted the government’s commitment to sustainability and inclusivity within the country’s palm oil value chain.

He emphasised that approximately 450,000 smallholders are the backbone of the sector and must not be excluded from sustainability initiatives.

“Unlike some international certification schemes that often overlook smallholders, the MSPO positions them as a key element, and the government also supports them by covering the cost of certification audits,” he said. — Bernama

‘I want to retire at my peak’: Anthony Loke reportedly sets 2031 exit from party, electoral positions





‘I want to retire at my peak’: Anthony Loke reportedly sets 2031 exit from party, electoral positions



DAP’s Anthony Loke has reportedly set a retirement timeline, saying he will not only abide by the party’s three-term limit for secretary-general but also step away from all leadership and electoral roles thereafter. — Bernama pic

Friday, 18 Apr 2025 4:17 PM MYT


KUALA LUMPUR, April 18 — DAP’s Anthony Loke has reportedly set a “retirement timeline” for himself, stating he plans to step away from his political roles after his third term as part secretary-general.

According to a report in Malaysiakini, he said that he will abide by the DAP constitution — which restricts the secretary-general to three terms — and has no intention of seeking other positions, such as national chairperson or Central Executive Committee (CEC) member.


“I want to retire at my peak – not wait until people no longer want me. That’s not how I intend to go. I want to decide my own path and political journey,” the transport minister was quoted as saying.

According to the report, if Loke is reelected for a final term, it would run until 2031, ending when he turns 54, and he does not plan to stand for Parliament or state assembly after that either.


Loke reportedly said that he considers his current roles as secretary-general and cabinet minister the peak of his political career.


He reportedly added that his final term would focus on implementing bolder reforms and making DAP more future ready — by making space for younger leaders.

“If we don’t start creating opportunities now for those in their 20s and 30s, the party will age significantly in 10 to 20 years.”


“Right now, I can’t go all the way. But in my last term, I’ll be more daring — nothing to lose, no fear of offending people,” he was quoted as saying.

Anwar calls for care in displaying national symbols after Sin Chew’s Jalur Gemilang gaffe





Anwar calls for care in displaying national symbols after Sin Chew’s Jalur Gemilang gaffe



Anwar urged all parties to exercise caution when depicting the national flag and also called for calm in public reaction to the error. — Bernama pic

Friday, 18 Apr 2025 3:19 PM MYT


KUALA LUMPUR, April 18 — The omission of the crescent moon from the Malaysian flag in a front-page illustration by Sin Chew Daily is not a trivial error, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim said today, stressing that a national flag is a vital symbol for any country.

According to Buletin TV3, Anwar urged all parties to exercise caution when depicting the national flag.


“For any country, the flag is a very important symbol. So, I advise everyone to be careful, but of course, Sin Chew Daily should be given the opportunity to explain the mistake and apologise.

“But this is not a minor issue. Let the legal process take its course,” he said at a press conference after concluding his official visit to Thailand at the invitation of his counterpart, Paetongtarn Shinawatra.


Anwar was responding to a question about Tuesday’s incident involving a front-page depiction of the Jalur Gemilang without its crescent moon.


He also called for calm in public reaction to the matter.

“I also advised that we should not overreact simply because of pressure; it has to follow the legal process,” he added.


Sin Chew Daily has since apologised for the error, attributing it to an unintentional technical mistake. The paper also announced the immediate suspension of its chief editor and deputy chief editor.

Both editors were detained last night as part of a police probe and have since been released on bail.

Police are investigating the case under Section 3(1)(c) of the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act 1963 and Section 4(1)(b) of the Printing Presses and Publications Act 1984.


‘Cover for political agenda’: Hamas rejects Israel’s truce proposal as Gaza air strikes kill 40 in camps for displaced civilians





‘Cover for political agenda’: Hamas rejects Israel’s truce proposal as Gaza air strikes kill 40 in camps for displaced civilians



Palestinians look on during the handover by Hamas of deceased hostages, identified at the time by Palestinian militant groups as Oded Lifschitz, Shiri Bibas and her two children Kfir and Ariel Bibas, seized during the deadly October 7, 2023 attack, to the Red Cross. — Reuters pic

Friday, 18 Apr 2025 9:10 AM MYT



GAZA CITY, April 18 — Hamas yesterday signalled its rejection of Israel’s latest truce proposal and called for a “comprehensive” deal to end the 18-month-long war.

The Palestinian militants’ chief negotiator spoke out after civil defence rescuers in Gaza said new Israeli air strikes killed at least 40 people, most of them in camps for displaced civilians, as Israel pressed its offensive in the Palestinian territory.


The Israeli military said it was looking into reports of the strikes.

A Hamas source told AFP that the group sent a written response Thursday to mediators on Israel’s latest proposal for a 45-day ceasefire. Israel had wanted the release of 10 living hostages held by the group, according to Hamas.


It also called for the freeing of 1,231 Palestinian prisoners from Israeli jails and the entry of humanitarian aid into Gaza, which has been under complete blockade since March 2.


The proposal called for Hamas to disarm to secure a complete end to the war, a demand the group rejects.

“Partial agreements are used by (Israeli Prime Minister) Benjamin Netanyahu as a cover for his political agenda... we will not be complicit in this policy,” Hamas’s chief negotiator, Khalil al-Hayya, said in a televised statement.


He said Hamas “seeks a comprehensive deal involving a single-package prisoner exchange in return for halting the war, a withdrawal of the occupation from the Gaza Strip, and the commencement of reconstruction” in the territory.

A previous ceasefire and hostage release deal began on January 19 but collapsed two months later.

Israel offered to extend the first phase, while Hamas insisted that negotiations be held for a second phase, as outlined by Joe Biden when he was US president.

Israel resumed intensive bombing of Gaza on March 18.

Qatar blames Israel

The emir of Qatar, which with Egypt and the United States helped mediate the January ceasefire, blamed Israel on Thursday for its collapse.

“As you know, we reached an agreement months ago, but unfortunately Israel did not abide by this agreement,” Sheikh Tamim bin Hamad Al-Thani said during a visit to Moscow.

Civil defence spokesman Mahmud Bassal said two Israeli missiles hit tents in the Al-Mawasi area of the southern city of Khan Yunis, killing at least 16 people, “most of them women and children, and 23 others were wounded”.

Tens of thousands of Palestinians flocked to Al-Mawasi after Israel declared it a safe zone in December 2023. But the area has since been hit by repeated Israeli strikes.

Survivors described a large explosion at the densely packed camp that set tents ablaze.

“We were sitting peacefully in the tent, under God’s protection, when we suddenly saw something red glowing — and then the tent exploded, and the surrounding tents caught fire,” Israa Abu al-Rus told AFP.

Bassal said Israeli strikes on two other camps for displaced Gazans killed a nine people — seven in the northern town of Beit Lahia, and a father and son near Al-Mawasi.

Separately, the civil defence reported two attacks in Jabalia — one that killed at least seven members of the Asaliya family, and another that killed six people at a school being used as a shelter — as well as Israeli shelling in Gaza City that killed two.

The military announced it had carried out a strike in Jabalia on a Hamas “command and control” centre.

Israel said Wednesday that it had converted 30 percent of Gaza into a buffer zone in its widening offensive.

The United Nations said half a million Palestinians have been displaced since the offensive resumed, triggering what it has described as the most severe humanitarian crisis since the war began with Hamas’s October 7, 2023 attack on Israel.

Red Cross base

Hamas accused Israel of attempting to starve Gaza’s 2.4 million people after Defence Minister Israel Katz said Wednesday that Israel would continue preventing aid from entering the territory.

“This is a public admission of committing a war crime,” the group said in a statement.

Medical supplies, fuel, water and other essentials are in short supply, the UN says.

The International Committee of the Red Cross, said it was “outraged” that an explosive hit one of its bases in Gaza on Wednesday, the second such strike in three weeks.

Israel’s renewed assault has killed at least 1,691 people in Gaza, the health ministry in the Hamas-run territory reported, bringing the overall toll since the war erupted to 51,065, most of them civilians.

Hamas’s October 2023 attack on Israel resulted in the deaths of 1,218 people, also mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official Israeli figures. — AFP


Beware the rise of the unaccountable bench


FMT:

Beware the rise of the unaccountable bench



Letter to the Editor

We do not preserve the rule of law by sidelining democracy – we uphold it when each institution performs its role within the framework of the constitution




From Apandi Ali

The debate over judicial appointments in Malaysia has intensified recently with a few people, from legal scholars to legal practitioners, defending Chief Justice Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat’s call for greater insulation of the judiciary from executive oversight.


They suggest that the prime minister’s power to reject names recommended by the Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) is antithetical to judicial independence, and that judges should be appointed based solely on merit, free from political preference.

While such views are often well-intentioned, they run the risk of enabling a new problem: the slow emergence of an unaccountable bench, a judiciary that answers to no one, yet wields the power to reshape public life through constitutional interpretation.


The call to entirely remove the prime minister’s role from judicial appointments would tilt the constitutional balance and, paradoxically, endanger the very accountability that protects democratic institutions from overreach.

Malaysia’s constitutional framework is clear. Under Article 122B of the Federal Constitution, judges of the superior courts are appointed by the Yang di-Pertuan Agong on the advice of the prime minister, after consultation with the chief justice and Conference of Rulers.

JAC, established by statute in 2009, plays a vital role in vetting and recommending candidates – but it is not, and never was, intended to displace the constitutional role of the executive.

To suggest that JAC’s recommendations must be binding – effectively removing the prime minister’s discretion – is to propose a judiciary accountable only to itself. This represents a shift from independence to isolationism.


As many constitutional scholars have warned, independence of the judiciary does not mean that judges are to be left in splendid isolation. This reflects a fundamental truth: no branch of government can be left completely unchecked.

The judiciary, by design, is unelected. It draws legitimacy not from the ballot box, but from its adherence to constitutional and legal norms.

The prime minister, on the other hand, is elected by the people and accountable to Parliament. His role in the judicial appointment process is the public’s only indirect influence over who interprets the laws they vote for.

To remove this role entirely is to cut off that connection, leaving judicial ideology to evolve within an echo chamber of legal insiders – potentially out of step with the cultural, social, and moral expectations of the nation.


Merit is essential, but merit must be evaluated in context, not in abstraction. Legal excellence alone is insufficient without the humility to serve in a system of shared powers and mutual accountability.

Supporters of judicial insulation often cite global examples, but executive involvement in judicial appointments is standard even in established democracies.

In Singapore, judges are appointed by the president on the advice of the prime minister. In the UK, the lord chancellor – a political office – still plays a formal role. In the US, federal judges are nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate.

These models do not diminish judicial independence – they reinforce it through institutional checks, public trust, and shared responsibility.

Recent Malaysian court decisions have revived the controversial basic structure doctrine, allowing courts to invalidate laws that allegedly offend the “basic structure” of the constitution – a concept never explicitly codified.

This doctrine, borrowed from India, has led to increasing concerns about judicial supremacy in a system meant to be balanced by three co-equal branches.


India, where the phrase “tyranny of the unelected” was coined to describe judicial overreach, is already grappling with the consequences of an overly assertive bench.

Malaysia should take heed before walking the same path.

If judges can strike down laws based on unwritten principles – and also determine who joins their ranks – we risk creating an ideological monopoly within the judiciary, unmoored from public accountability.

These people’s support for judicial independence is understandable, but their proposal risks swinging the pendulum too far.

Instead of removing the prime minister’s role, we should focus on refining the appointment process: strengthen JAC, improve transparency, and require reasoned decisions where appropriate.

We cannot abandon the prime minister’s role entirely. The judiciary must be independent, yes – but it must also remain connected to the people’s mandate through a process of balanced, constitutional design.

We do not preserve the rule of law by sidelining democracy. We uphold it when each institution – judiciary, executive, and legislature – performs its role within the framework laid out by the constitution.

Independence without restraint is not strength. In time, it will be a threat to the very freedoms it seeks to protect.



Apandi Ali is a former attorney-general.

Sin Chew editors' detention: I'm ashamed to be Malaysian, says don










Sin Chew editors' detention: I'm ashamed to be Malaysian, says don


RK Anand
Published: Apr 18, 2025 8:30 AM
Updated: 10:30 AM




Summary

  • Academic Tajuddin Rasdi does not mince words in wondering if Malaysia has become a failed nation.

  • He condemns those who cling to a “sorry, no cure” attitude and demand their “pound of flesh”.


Academic Tajuddin Rasdi has voiced his profound concern and dismay over the detention of two senior editors from Sin Chew Daily, declaring bluntly that he feels a deep sense of shame in being Malaysian.

“This incident reinforces my long-held belief that our country is teetering on the edge of becoming a failed nation - or perhaps has already fallen into an abyss with no end,” he told Malaysiakini.

Tajuddin said he even disagreed with the daily’s decision to suspend the editors for inadvertently publishing an image of the Jalur Gemilang without the crescent moon symbol.

The professor of architecture agreed with the view that, since Sin Chew has apologised, corrected the mistake, and committed to reviewing its procedures for using artificial intelligence, this should be considered sufficient.

Academic Tajuddin Rasdi


“How can we aspire to be a family that allows no room for mistakes? How can we become a family or a nation that offers no space for learning, no grace for self-correction?

“What kind of family, company, or country abandons the understanding that to err is human, and to forgive, divine?” he asked.

Tajuddin said while there are numerous groups who cite the “divine”, there appeared to be a glaring dearth in dearth of “divine compassion”.

‘Sorry no cure’

Clinging to a “sorry, no cure” attitude and constantly demanding a “pound of flesh”, he argued that Malaysians have failed to learn from several incidents, including the KK Mart controversy, the Era FM issue, and the temple relocation case.

“I wonder what religion teaches its adherents the principle of ‘sorry no cure’?

“Even Prophet Muhammad forgave the people who caused him immense hardship in Taif. I take inspiration from my prophet, but I wonder, those who demand their pound of flesh - where did they learn their faith from?

“Truly, today I feel ashamed to be called a 'Malaysian’,” he emphasised.

Inspector-General of Police Razarudin Husain


Yesterday, Inspector-General of Police Razaruddin Hussain said the chief editor and deputy chief sub-editor of Sin Chew Daily were detained to assist in investigations and would be released on police bail later.

Earlier, the duo had their statements recorded over a three-hour session at the Classified Criminal Investigation Unit office in Bukit Aman.

Police also revealed that 40 reports were lodged nationwide over the matter.


***


kt comments:

Some Malaysians want to punish, hurt, condemn etc etc whenever the opportunity arises - and it's getting worse each day

Soon it may even come to these (see below):






Zaid: Execute investigators, prosecutors enabling corruptio









Zaid: Execute investigators, prosecutors enabling corruption


RK Anand
Published: Apr 17, 2025 8:18 PM
Updated: 10:18 PM




Summary

  • Zaid Ibrahim criticises a Sabah assemblyperson’s suggestion to execute graft offenders by firing squad.

  • The former law minister says enforcement, not harsher laws, is the real issue.


In a twist that sounds like it belongs in a dystopian political thriller, a Sabah politician proposed that graft offenders be executed by firing squad, like in China.

However, former law minister Zaid Ibrahim responded with a sharp critique, warning that such a policy "might not just trim the fat - it could massacre the entire buffet”.

By his conservative estimate, Zaid claimed that implementing such a law would eliminate at least 80 percent of Malaysian politicians, leaving state assemblies - including the one in Kota Kinabalu - and Parliament in Kuala Lumpur resembling abandoned buildings.

"On the flipside. The ideological tortoises in this race of gold-chasing hares - the politicians who don’t treat politics as a get-rich-quick scheme - might finally have an edge,” he told Malaysiakini.

While making clear he does not support the death penalty, Zaid (above) argued that if executions were to be considered, then the "silver bullet" solution would be to first target those who refuse to investigate or prosecute corruption, particularly when it involves those in power.



"The existing laws are sufficient to address and discourage corruption," he said.

"But it’s the implementation that has always been lacking. For decades, we’ve seen how enforcement agencies are weaponised against political rivals while acting as shields for those in power.

“Execute a few of them and everyone will be on their best behaviour, including the politicians,” he added.

In a tongue-in-cheek take on the Warisan assemblyperson’s proposal, Zaid said such a law would never be passed as it would be asking politicians to sign their death warrants.

“If nothing else, it’s a great conversation starter over your next teh tarik,” he added.

Ongoing corruption scandal

Earlier, Malaysiakini reported Bugaya assemblyperson Jamil Hamzah as mooting the firing squad solution during the ongoing state assembly proceedings in Sabah.

His proposal came amid an ongoing corruption scandal involving the Gabungan Rakyat Sabah state administration.

Bugaya assemblyperson Jamil Hamzah


Since November last year, a businessperson has released a series of videos and screenshots of WhatsApp conversations implicating eight GRS assemblypersons, as well as the state legislative assembly speaker, Kadzim Yahya.

The businessperson, who claims to possess additional videos, alleged that he bribed the politicians in exchange for mineral exploration licences.

Chief Minister Hajiji Noor has accused the individual of colluding with certain parties to discredit his administration ahead of the upcoming state election.

The businessperson is also accused of being part of a cartel attempting to monopolise mining activities in the state.

On April 10, MACC chief commissioner Azam Baki said the commission was waiting for the forensic analysis report into the Sabah scandal videos, which were submitted on March 11.


Anwar holds ‘frank, constructive’ talk with Myanmar’s junta head


FMT:

Anwar holds ‘frank, constructive’ talk with Myanmar’s junta head



7 hours ago

Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim says the discussion also touched on the importance of returning Myanmar to ‘normalcy’ after a 2021 coup.


Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim met Myanmar’s junta leader Min Aung Hlaing in Bangkok today.


PETALING JAYA: Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim said he had a “frank and constructive” discussion with Myanmar’s junta leader Min Aung Hlaing today.



In a Facebook post, Anwar said their discussion touched, among others, on the importance of “returning the country to normalcy”, adding that he would also meet with representatives of the National Unity Government (NUG).


The NUG and National Unity Consultative Council (NUCC) form the Myanmar government-in-exile, which was established after a 2021 military coup that sparked widespread protests and civil unrest across the country.

Civil rights groups say the junta has arrested thousands of protesters and activists since the coup, which saw its military overthrow the democratically-elected government of Aung San Suu Kyi and the National League for Democracy.


The coup plunged the nation into a multi-sided civil war which has seen at least three million people displaced, according to the United Nations.

Myanmar’s military government yesterday said it would release nearly 5,000 prisoners in an amnesty to mark the country’s new year festivities, reported AFP.

“I welcome recent steps to ease tensions, including the release last night of 4,800 detainees. Such gestures are a meaningful signal,” said Anwar.

Anwar also encouraged all parties to “engage seriously” in the interest of Myanmar’s stability and the wellbeing of its people.


Asean – which Malaysia is chairing this year – wants Myanmar to implement a five-point peace plan to halt the fighting, with the ruling generals barred from attending its meetings over their failure to comply.

He said he and Min discussed the immediate deployment of a field hospital in the country after the recent earthquake.

The devastating 7.7-magnitude earthquake that struck Myanmar on March 28 has claimed more than 5,300 lives and compounded the already critical humanitarian crisis in the country amid the civil war.

Yesterday, foreign minister Mohamad Hasan said the mission to deploy medical officers to Myanmar to set up a field hospital was postponed at the request of Myanmar’s authorities.


Newsman’s view: An honest mistake probably yet heads must roll in Sin Chew’s Malaysian flag blunder





Newsman’s view: An honest mistake probably yet heads must roll in Sin Chew’s Malaysian flag blunder






GHOSTS of publishing are very difficult to exorcise. You could have taken utmost precaution with your content or have 10 eagle-eyed editors with 30 years of industry experience vetted it yet one silliest of mistake sneaked through.


Such scenario – coupled with tight deadline and manpower constraint, a phenomenon which is evident across newsrooms the world over today – could have led to a costly or earth-shattering oversight.


Sadly, the rather outstanding artistic conceptualisation of the Chinese jong as a symbolic gesture to welcome the landmark state visit of China’s president Xi Jinping has literally gone down the dustbin with the Sin Chew Daily’s omission of the crescent moon in Jalur Gemilang.




All of a sudden, all the good intention and hard work poured into laying out the April 15, 2025 edition of one of Malaysia’s top two Chinese newspapers is forgotten with jury aplenty out there to demonise the publication.


Such is perhaps the cruelty of journalism where editors constantly live with a sword of Damocles hanging over their head.


Irony or otherwise, this certainly sends a chilling message to all counterparts as to how the crescent moon (a symbol representing Islam as the religion of the Federation) is capable of bringing down Sin Chew Daily’s reputation that has been built over a span of 96 years to its knees.


His Majesty Sultan Ibrahim, King of Malaysia rightly pointed out that a flag is not just a “colourful piece of patterned cloth” but represents the struggle, history, the meaning of independence and the spirit of the common people.



“The mistake of displaying a picture of the Jalur Gemilang without a crescent moon as published on the front page of a local Chinese-language newspaper could trigger the people’s sensitivities and is unacceptable,” he penned on his Facebook page.


In all probability, Sin Chew Daily deserves to be reprimanded – heads must roll even if it must earmark a fall guy to take the wrap – but certainly not to the extent of revoking its publishing licence as taunted by some detractors.

Despite having 13 police reports already lodged against it with investigation underway under Section 4(1)(b) of the Printing Presses and Publishing Act 1984, a pertinent point is that Sin Chew Daily has issued a tri-lingual apology in English, Bahasa Malaysia, and Chinese.

“This was an unintentional error made during the design process,” the paper clarified. “We’ve amended the digital version and the same notice will be published in the print version.

“We apologise unreservedly to our readers, members of the Malaysian community and the general public. We regret the error.”

As the Home Ministry has issued a show-cause letter and initiated an investigation into the matter, it is of paramount importance for the relevant authorities to filter out political noises that can be toxic in their decision-making process.

As rightly argued by Gerakan Media Merdeka (GERAMM), while Sin Chew Daily must be accountable for the blunder, reactions must be measured while refraining the use of outdated laws.

“We strongly condemn any calls for extreme action, including public boycotts, harassment of media workers or punitive measures under outdated laws like the Printing Presses and Publications Act 1984 (PPPA),” stressed the journalist group that advocates for a free and independent media in a statement.

“These reactions don’t contribute to constructive discourse and only serve to endanger media freedom in Malaysia.”

As it is, Sin Chew Daily has conducted a thorough internal review on the matter with the personnel responsible for the error subjected to disciplinary action.

Interestingly, its editorial department has also reviewed procedures, particularly with regard to the use of artificial intelligence (AI) which could have contributed to the oversight.

“We pledge to be extra cautious and sensitive in handling matters that may harm national dignity and interracial relations,” added the daily. – April 17, 2025



Sin Chew Daily takes action over ‘serious lapse’ involving Malaysian flag, suspends senior staff





Sin Chew Daily takes action over ‘serious lapse’ involving Malaysian flag, suspends senior staff




Screencap of vernacular Chinese newspaper Sin Chew Daily announcing the suspension of two senior staff on its Mandarin website, after the publication of a front page gaffe of the Malaysian flag.

Thursday, 17 Apr 2025 7:14 PM MYT


KUALA LUMPUR, April 17 — Malaysia’s largest Chinese-language newspaper Sin Chew Daily today announced the suspension of both its chief editor and deputy chief sub-editor over an error involving the Malaysian flag published on its front page.

In a brief two paragraph statement in Mandarin published on its news portal, Sin Chew Daily said the suspensions are effective immediately and will remain until investigations into the issue are completed.


The Chinese-language newspaper had published an incomplete illustration of the Jalur Gemilang, without the crescent moon, on its front page last Tuesday in conjunction with the coverage of Chinese President Xi Jinping’s state visit to Malaysia.

Earlier today, federal police summoned Sin Chew Daily chief editor and deputy chief sub-editor to record their statements at the Classified Crime Investigation Unit Office in Bukit Aman.


The case is being investigated under Section 3(1)(c) of the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act 1963 and Section 4(1)(b) of the Printing Presses and Publications Act 1984.


Inspector-General of Police Tan Sri Razarudin Husain was reported as saying the chief editor was the person responsible for approving the publication of the illustration, while the deputy chief sub editor was the graphic designer of the flag illustration.

The vernacular newspaper issued an unreserved apology yesterday to His Majesty Sultan Ibrahim, the King of Malaysia, while acknowledging the King’s advice and described the mistake involving the Jalur Gemilang as a serious lapse.


The Home Ministry has also issued a show-cause letter to the newspaper over the incident, stressing that the Jalur Gemilang must be treated with respect as it symbolises national sovereignty, unity, and identity.


***


kt comments:

Media people in Malaysia have to walk on egg shells at all times



Zelensky accuses China of supplying Russia with weapons

FMT:

Zelensky accuses China of supplying Russia with weapons


Zelensky accuses China of supplying Russia with weapons

2 hours ago

The allegation comes after 155 Chinese citizens were reportedly found fighting for the Russian military last week.


President Volodymyr Zelensky said that Chinese representatives were involved in weapon production on Russian territory, without giving further details. (AP pic)


KYIV: Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky said on Thursday China was supplying weapons and gunpowder to Russia, the first time he has openly accused Beijing of direct military assistance for Moscow.



The Ukrainian leader said at a press conference that his government also had intelligence that China was producing weapons on Russian territory and that he would be able to provide more details next week.


China, which has the world’s second-largest economy, has had close economic relations with Russia during Moscow’s three-year war in Ukraine. But it has sought to project an image of neutrality and denies any involvement in the war.

For Kyiv, direct Chinese supplies of weaponry for Russia would mark a major departure from that position.



“We finally have information that China is supplying weapons to the Russian Federation,” Zelensky said in Kyiv, referring specifically to “artillery,” without specifying if he meant shells, artillery systems or both.

“We believe that Chinese representatives are engaged in the production of some weapons on the territory of Russia,” Zelensky said, without elaborating.

There was no immediate public comment from China and Reuters was not immediately able to seek comment from officials in China, as Zelensky’s remarks were made during the late evening in Beijing.

In comments last week about the war, China’s foreign ministry spokesperson Lin Jian said: “I would like to reiterate that China is not the initiator of the Ukrainian crisis, nor is China a participating party. We are a firm supporter and active promoter of a peaceful settlement of the crisis.”


Zelensky’s allegation comes as President Donald Trump is pressing for peace, having upended previous US policy by directly engaging with Russia and at one point cutting military aid to Ukraine.

The Ukrainian leader said he had spoken to Chinese President Xi Jinping during the war and asked him directly about the possibility of Beijing supplying arms to Russia.

“He gave me his word that weapons would not be sold and sent to Russia,” he said.

Strained ties


Russia has benefited from military aid from Iran and North Korea. Tehran has supplied long-range drones used to attack far from the front, while Pyongyang has supplied vast amounts of artillery shells, missiles and troops, Ukrainian officials say.

The fighting in Ukraine has long developed into a war of attrition in which both sides try to out-gun and out-kill each other by bringing greater numbers of troops and weapons to bear, making foreign military supplies vital.

Ties between China and Ukraine are already strained after Zelensky made public this month its capture of two Chinese nationals fighting for Russia.

He said last week that Ukraine had information about 155 Chinese citizens fighting for the Russian military against Kyiv’s forces.

Zelensky said at that time that Russia was recruiting Chinese nationals via social media and that Beijing officials were aware of that. He added that Ukraine was trying to assess whether the recruits were receiving instructions from Beijing.

A week ago, China reaffirmed its support for peace efforts in Ukraine and said relevant parties should avoid “irresponsible remarks,” in an apparent jab at Zelensky’s comment about Chinese citizens fighting there for Russia.

Two U.S. officials familiar with American intelligence and a former Western intelligence official told Reuters last week they believed the Chinese citizens were mercenaries who did not appear to have a direct link to China’s government.

China and Russia declared a “no limits” strategic partnership days before Russian President Vladimir Putin sent tens of thousands of troops into Ukraine in February 2022.


Police wrap up investigation into Sin Chew’s Jalur Gemilang front page gaffe





Police wrap up investigation into Sin Chew’s Jalur Gemilang front page gaffe



Police have completed recording statements from the Chief Editor and Deputy Chief Sub-editor of the Sin Chew Daily newspaper today to assist in investigations into the publication of an incomplete illustration of the Jalur Gemilang on the newspaper’s front page. — Picture by Choo Choy May

Thursday, 17 Apr 2025 7:34 PM MYT


KUALA LUMPUR, April 17 — Police have completed recording statements from the Chief Editor and Deputy Chief Sub-editor of the Sin Chew Daily newspaper today to assist in investigations into the publication of an incomplete illustration of the Jalur Gemilang on the newspaper’s front page.

Inspector-General of Police Tan Sri Razarudin Husain said the process took about three hours at the Classified Crime Investigation Unit office at the Royal Malaysia Police (PDRM) headquarters in Bukit Aman.

“The entire process was completed at 3.45 pm,” he said when contacted today.

The Chief Editor was said to have approved the publication of the illustration, while the Deputy Chief Sub-editor was responsible for designing the graphic.

Razarudin said so far police have received 40 reports nationwide regarding the issue. The case is being investigated under Section 3(1)© of the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act 1963 and Section 4(1)(b) of the Printing Presses and Publications Act 1984.

On Tuesday, the Chinese-language daily published an illustration of the Jalur Gemilang on its front page in conjunction with coverage of Chinese President Xi Jinping’s state visit to Malaysia, but the flag appeared incomplete.

The incident drew criticism from various parties, including His Majesty Sultan Ibrahim, King of Malaysia, who said the newspaper’s management and editorial department must be more careful and thoroughly vet materials before publication.

Following the backlash, the newspaper issued an apology, stating that the mistake was a technical error and unintentional. — Bernama


Thursday, April 17, 2025

Israel is about to empty Gaza


Pearls and Irritations
John Menadue's Public Policy Journal




April 17, 2025


As Israel prepares to ethnically cleanse the whole of Gaza, it is also setting the stage for a regional crisis.

Israel is poised to carry out the largest campaign of ethnic cleansing since the end of World War II. Since 2 March, it has blocked all food and humanitarian aid into Gaza and cut off electricity, so that the last water desalination plant no longer functions.

The Israeli military has seized half of the territory — Gaza is 25 miles long and four to five miles wide — and placed two-thirds of Gaza under displacement orders, rendered “no-go zones”, including the border town of Rafah, which is encircled by Israeli troops.

On 11 April, Defence Minister Israel Katz announced that Israel would “intensify” the war against Hamas and use “all military and civilian pressure, including evacuation of the Gaza population south and implementing US President [Donald] Trump’s voluntary migration plan for Gaza residents".

Since Israel’s unilateral ending of the ceasefire on 18 March — which was never honoured by Israel — Israel has been carrying out relentless bombing and shelling against civilians, killing more than 1400 Palestinians and wounding more than 3600, according to the Palestinian health ministry.

An average of 100 children are being killed daily, according to the United Nations. Israel is, at the same time, inciting tensions with Egypt to lay what I suspect will be the groundwork for a mass expulsion of Palestinians into the Egyptian Sinai.

Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, echoing Katz, said Israel would not lift the total blockade until Hamas was “defeated” and the remaining 59 Israeli hostages released.

“Not even a grain of wheat will enter Gaza,” he vowed.

But no-one in Israel or Gaza expects Hamas, which has weathered the decimation of Gaza and sustained mass slaughter, to surrender or disappear.

The question no longer is will the Palestinians be deported from Gaza but when they will be pushed out and where they will go. The Israeli leadership is apparently torn between driving Palestinians over the border into Egypt or shipping them to countries in Africa. The US and Israel have contacted three East African governments — Sudan, Somalia and the breakaway region of Somalia known as Somaliland — to discuss the resettlement of ethnically cleansed Palestinians.

The consequences of wholesale ethnic cleansing will be catastrophic, jeopardising the stability of the Arab regimes allied with Washington and setting off firestorms of protests within Arab countries. It will likely mean the severing of diplomatic relations between Israel and its neighbours, Jordan and Egypt, already close to the breaking point, and push the region closer to war.

Diplomatic relations have fallen to their lowest point since the signing of the Camp David Accords in 1979. The Israeli embassies in Cairo and Amman are largely empty, with Israeli staff withdrawn over security concerns following the 7 October 2023 incursion into Israel by Hamas and other armed Palestinian factions.

Egypt has refused to accept the credentials of Uri Rothman, who was appointed to be the Israeli ambassador last September. Egypt did not name a new ambassador to Israel when former ambassador, Khaled Azmi, was recalled last year.

Israeli officials are accusing Egypt of violating the Camp David Accords by increasing its military presence and building new military installations in the Northern Sinai, charges Egypt says are fabricated. The peace treaty’s annex permits additional Egyptian military hardware in the Sinai.

Former Israeli chief of the general staff, Herzi Halevi, warned of what he calls Egypt’s “security threat”. Katz said Israel would not allow Egypt to “violate the peace treaty” between the two countries which was signed in 1979.

Egyptian officials note that it is Israel that has violated the treaty by occupying the Philadelphi Corridor, also known as the Salahuddin Axis, which runs along the nine-mile border between Gaza and Egypt and is supposed to be demilitarised.

“Every Israeli action along Gaza’s border with Egypt constitutes hostile behaviour against Egypt’s national security,” Egyptian General Mohammed Rashad, a former military intelligence chief, told the Arabic language newspaper, Asharq Al-Awsat.

“Egypt cannot sit idly by in the face of such threats and must prepare for all possible scenarios.”

Israeli officials are openly calling for the “voluntary transfer” of Palestinians to Egypt. Knesset member Avigdor Lieberman stated that “displacing most Palestinians from Gaza to the Egyptian Sinai is a practical and effective solution".

He contrasted the high population density — Gaza is one of the most densely populated places on the planet — with the vast “untapped lands” in the Egyptian Northern Sinai and noted that Palestinians share a common culture and language with Egypt, making any deportation “natural".

He also criticised Egypt because it allegedly “benefits economically from the current political situation” as a mediator between Israel and Hamas and “reaps profits from smuggling operations through the tunnels and the Rafah crossing".

The Israeli think-tank Misgav Institute for National Security, staffed by former Israeli military and security officials, published a paper on 17 October 2023, calling on the government to take advantage of the “unique and rare opportunity to evacuate the entire Gaza Strip”, and resettle Palestinians in Cairo with the assistance of the Egyptian Government.

A leaked document from the Israeli Intelligence Ministry proposed resettling Palestinians from Gaza in the Northern Sinai and constructing barriers and buffer zones to prevent their return.

Any expulsion is likely to happen swiftly, with Israeli forces, which are already mercilessly herding Palestinians into containment areas in Gaza, carrying out a sustained bombing campaign against the trapped Palestinians while creating porous evacuation portals along the border with Egypt.

It would entail a potentially lethal standoff with the Egyptian military, instantly throwing the Egyptian regime of Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, who has described any ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians in Gaza as a “red line”, into crisis.

It would be a short step from there to a regional conflict.

Israel has seized territory in Syria and southern Lebanon, part of its vision of “Greater Israel”, which includes occupying land in Egypt, Jordan and Saudi Arabia. It covets the maritime gas fields off Gaza’s coast and has floated plans for a new canal to bypass the Suez Canal, to connect Israel’s bankrupt Eilat Port on the Red Sea to the Mediterranean Sea. These projects require emptying Gaza of Palestinians and populating it with Jewish colonists.

The anger on the Arab street — an anger I witnessed over the past few months during visits to Egypt, Jordan, the West Bank and Qatar — will explode in a justifiable fury if mass deportation takes place. These regimes, simply to hold on to power, will be forced to act. Terrorist attacks, whether by organised groups or lone wolves, will proliferate against Israeli and Western targets, especially the United States.

The genocide is a recruitment dream for Islamic militants. Washington and Israel must, on some level, understand the cost of this savagery. But it appears as though they accept it, foolishly trying to obliterate those they have cast out of the community of nations, those they refer to as “human animals".

What do Israel and Washington believe will happen when the Palestinians are expelled from a land they have lived in for centuries? How do they think a people who are desperate, deprived of hope, dignity and a way to make a living, who are being butchered by one of the most technologically advanced armies on the planet, will respond?

Do they think creating a Dantesque hell for the Palestinians will blunt terrorism, curb suicide attacks and foster peace? Can they not grasp the rage rippling through the Middle East and how it will implant a hatred towards us that will endure for decades?

The genocide in Gaza is the greatest crime of this century. It will come back to haunt Israel. It will come back to haunt us. It will usher to our doorsteps the evil we have perpetrated on the Palestinians.

You reap what you sow. We have sown a minefield of hatred and violence.



Republished from Consortium News, 14 April


Federal Court’s ruling in Loh Siew Hong case strengthens landmark precedent on unilateral conversion of minors



Murray Hunter


Federal Court’s ruling in Loh Siew Hong case strengthens landmark precedent on unilateral conversion of minors


P Ramasamy
Apr 16, 2025





The Federal Court of Malaysia has reaffirmed the earlier decision by the Court of Appeal in maintaining the religious status of Loh Siew Hong’s three underaged children as Hindus, reinforcing the 2018 landmark decision in the Indira Gandhi case which declared unilateral conversions of minors unconstitutional.

In rejecting the appeal by the Perlis state government, the Perlis Mufti, and other related religious authorities, the Federal Court clarified that its decision is binding in all future cases involving the unilateral religious conversion of minors.

The ruling serves as a clear message that the constitutional rights of both parents must be upheld in matters concerning the religious identity of their children.

One of the pivotal issues addressed was the interpretation of the word “parent” in Article 12(4) of the Federal Constitution. While the Bahasa Malaysia version uses the singular form “ibu atau bapa”, the Federal Court emphasized that the authoritative text is the English version of the Constitution, where “parent” should be interpreted in the plural as “parents”.

This means the consent of both parents is required for a valid conversion of a minor, nullifying attempts at unilateral conversion permitted under some state laws, such as in Perlis.

The court also reaffirmed that the Federal Constitution is the supreme law of the land and thus overrides any state enactment or constitution that allows for unilateral conversions.

This principle reinforces the doctrine of constitutional supremacy and the importance of harmonizing state laws with fundamental rights guaranteed at the federal level.

In its judgment, the court noted the profound impact unilateral conversions have on children, especially when executed without the knowledge or consent of one parent.

Such actions often result in long-term psychological and emotional harm, as well as legal complications concerning guardianship, custody, and religious upbringing.

The case of Indira Gandhi continues to stand as a significant legal precedent. Despite her personal heartbreak—her daughter remains missing, presumably hidden by her former husband who abducted her years ago—Indira’s relentless legal battle succeeded in establishing a constitutional safeguard for countless parents and children facing similar predicaments.

Sadly, efforts by authorities to locate and arrest her ex-husband have been minimal, raising questions about enforcement and justice.

Nonetheless, Indira’s courage and persistence have paved the way for others like Loh Siew Hong to challenge unlawful conversions. Loh, who regained custody of her children after they were taken and unilaterally converted by her former husband, benefited directly from the legal principles enshrined in the Indira Gandhi ruling.

This latest Federal Court decision marks another step forward in upholding constitutional rights, protecting the welfare of minors, and affirming the need for mutual parental consent in decisions of such profound personal and religious significance.



P. Ramasamy

Chairman Urimai

April 16, 2025