Sunday, June 05, 2022

AP abolition can strengthen food security, halt price hikes, says economist

The Star:

AP abolition can strengthen food security, halt price hikes, says economist





KUALA LUMPUR: The government’s move to abolish approved permits (APs) for food imports is viewed as a short-term solution as it allows markets to operate freely to strengthen the country’s food security and halt price hikes, says an economist.

Malaysia University of Science and Technology (MUST) economics professor Dr Geoffrey Williams said the government was doing the right thing in stages - from price caps to market liberalisation - to ensure sufficient food supply in the country.


ALSO READ: Make food security the country’s priority

"We should see the price pressure easing and this will benefit consumers in the short term.

"Then, if the APs are not reimposed, we should see more long-term benefits in terms of lower prices, more product options and better quality,” he told Bernama during a recent interview.

ALSO READ: We need long-term solutions, says Fomca

Recently, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Ismail Sabri Yaakob announced the government’s decision to abolish APs for food products immediately to ensure that the country has an adequate food supply.

Chicken is one of the food products that is currently in the spotlight due to the supply shortage.

ALSO READ: PM: Lifting AP requirement will ensure local supply is sufficient

Williams, who is also the MUST provost for research and innovation, said the abolishment of the APs was an important step towards creating open, free and transparent trade arrangements.

"It should be extended beyond food towards abolishing all APs and import restrictions except for health and safety reasons.

"This will promote business and trade, reduce prices for consumers and reduce costs for the government - a win-win-win solution - and will promote investments, jobs and growth as well as help to keep food prices down,” he added.

ALSO READ: Consumer groups want all food-related APs abolished

According to the Statistics Department Malaysia, over the last 10 years, Malaysia’s food imports amounted to RM482.8bil and exports at RM296bil.

In order to meet the domestic consumers’ needs and demands, it said imports of food products, especially onions, dairy products, coffee, wheat flour, tea, shallots, potato and cooking oil are necessary.

Meanwhile, Sunway University economics professor Dr Yeah Kim Leng said the food cartel members will have to face open market competition following the abolishment of the APs.

"But they will have an advantage if they have already established a distribution network and economy of scale in their operations,” he said.

ALSO READ: Birds at affordable prices on rakyat’s wish list

Yeah took note of the higher number of participants in the free market and expects the competition to result in increased market efficiency, price transparency and more choices for consumers.

However, he said in the short term, as long as supplies are available, the key challenge was to ensure that the low income households are able to cope with the rising food costs.

Hence, he suggested targeted food subsidies as an appropriate policy response.

ALSO READ: Agri Ministry to continue balancing imported food with local production

Meanwhile, Bank Islam Malaysia Bhd chief economist Dr Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid suggested for the government to implement initiatives that promote agricultural activities.

"Ideally, we should grow our own crops since the country has vast fertile land and the weather is conducive for agricultural products.

"However, there are structural issues (that need to be addressed) such as the over-concentration of cash crops like oil palm, as well as factors such as labour and capital in order to resuscitate the agricultural sector holistically,” added Mohd Afzanizam. - Bernama


Related stories:

Make food security the country’s priority

Boost domestic food output, stabilise prices, supply, urge experts

Agri Ministry to continue balancing imported food with local production

Govt policies will be adjusted to face economic challenges, says PM

Higher food prices fuel concerns


1 comment:

  1. We have to first question the rationale for the existence of APs.

    A similar but not the same is Singapore's Certificate of Entitlement (COE) for the purchase of a car in Singapore.

    There are 2 distinct advantages in the Singapore COE system:
    1) revenue collected is back into the country's coffers. So, the people benefit.
    2) it is used as a means to control the car population in Singapore and thus traffic congestion.

    Of course, Singapore still have the Electronic Road Pricing (ERP) (like toll collection) to augment the COE to control traffic. Again, the revenue generated goes back to the government.

    Whether we agree with the Singapore COE, the ultimate benefits go to the people because no individual or company is given the rights or contracts to manage the COE or ERP. So, there is no chance of corruption or cronyism.

    Can we say the same of our APs?

    ReplyDelete