
Penang CM: Guan Eng dismisses explanations, misleads the public
Chow raised the issue in response to criticism launched by Bagan MP Lim Guan Eng, who questioned the commitment to pay RM210 million annually over 40 years, totalling RM8.4 billion
Updated 3 minutes ago · Published on 19 Nov 2026 12:54PM

PENANG is facing a looming shortage of new raw water sources by 2030, prompting the state government to defend its RM8.4 billion agreement with Perak as essential to securing long-term supply.
Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow said all available surface water resources in Penang were expected to be fully utilised by 2030, while water demand was projected to exceed 1,100 million litres per day (MLD) by 2032.
He said the state could not afford to rely solely on existing sources, particularly its continued dependence on Sungai Muda, and described the bulk water supply agreement (BWSA) with Perak as a necessary long-term solution.
Chow, who chairs PBA Holdings Bhd (PBAHB) and Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP), was responding to criticism by Bagan MP Lim Guan Eng, who questioned the commitment to pay RM210 million annually over 40 years, totalling RM8.4 billion.
He said Lim had repeatedly criticised the agreement without offering a better alternative, potentially confusing the public over the need to safeguard Penang's water security.
Chow cited desalination as an alternative examined by the state but said internal PBAPP estimates showed that a plant with a capacity of 300 MLD could cost more than RM25 billion over its construction and operating lifespan of about 20 years.
Under the BWSA, Perak's Prasarana Air dan Irigasi Perak (PAIP) will supply between 300 and 500 MLD of treated water over 40 years through a dedicated 500 MLD water treatment plant estimated to cost RM3 billion to build.
However, financing and infrastructure renewal costs would bring the total capacity charges to RM8.4 billion, based on assessments by appointed financial consultants.
PAIP will secure financing, bear construction risks and manage maintenance and infrastructure upgrades, while PBAPP will not be required to make any upfront payment or capital contribution.
Instead, PBAPP will pay annual capacity charges of RM210 million from the commencement of water supply.
Chow said the overall contract value of RM24.6 billion comprised RM8.4 billion in capacity charges and RM16.2 billion in supply charges, with the latter payable only for water actually delivered and meeting agreed quality standards.
He said PAIP would be liable for compensation if it failed to meet the stipulated supply volume or water quality requirements, except in circumstances beyond its control, such as severe drought or when Perak's own needs took priority under the State Interest Clause.
The agreement also provides safeguards, including PBAPP's right to terminate the contract if PAIP breaches its terms and fails to remedy the breach within 90 days.
Chow said the agreement received 98 per cent support from votes cast at PBAHB's extraordinary general meeting on Nov 12, following repeated explanations through state legislative assembly sittings, special briefings to assemblymen and shareholder circulars.
He added that five PBAHB directors who had reservations about certain terms did not dispute the need for additional water supply, with their concerns focused on payment obligations if Perak invoked the State Interest Clause and the possibility of prolonged supply disruptions. - November 19, 2026

/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2023/03/516291ac793e38edc0a61de68a5810d3.jpg)
R Nadarajah
Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim and French President Emmanuel Macron at the temple
Thanga Ganesan

Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim/file/publisher-c1a3f893382d2b2f8a9aa22a654d9c97/2026/08/b5cbe2297f5f23dfd96999d31e059cef.jpg)
Former prime minister Najib Abdul Razak







