Friday, November 20, 2026

Umno prepared to sacrifice Ismail to retain power, says analyst

 


Umno prepared to sacrifice Ismail to retain power, says analyst

Umno prepared to sacrifice Ismail to retain power, says analyst

Azmi Hassan believes Umno is prioritising its hold on Negeri Sembilan, while Zaharuddin Sani warns that its handling of the episode could create an internal trust deficit.

ismail lasim tuanku muhriz
Ismail Lasim remains Negeri Sembilan’s menteri besar following a Nov 17 audience with Yang di-Pertuan Besar Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir.
PETALING JAYA:
Umno may be prepared to drop Ismail Lasim as menteri besar to stay in power in Negeri Sembilan, analysts said, warning that the episode could create a trust deficit within the party.

“I see Umno taking steps to sacrifice Ismail Lasim as menteri besar,” Azmi Hassan of Akademi Nusantara told FMT.

Azmi Hassan.

He said Ismail’s withdrawal was being viewed as a possible way to resolve the party’s standoff with the palace and preserve Barisan Nasional’s hold on the state government.

However, Ahmad Zaharuddin Sani Ahmad Sabri of Global Asia Consulting warned that the handling of Ismail’s purported resignation could create a trust deficit between Umno’s top leadership and the party’s lower-ranked leaders.

He said these leaders could question the need to remain loyal if they believed that adhering to party decisions could leave them bearing the brunt of any resulting fallout.

“If someone who has consistently followed party decisions can end up in such a predicament without a convincing explanation, what assurance is there that the same will not happen to other leaders?” he said.

His warning follows claims by Ismail’s son, Naim, that his father was being made the scapegoat for the political crisis that has arisen in Negeri Sembilan.

Responding to questions raised by Naim over whether his father had in fact resigned, Umno president Ahmad Zahid Hamidi said Ismail had stepped down voluntarily and without instructions from the party. The Umno president also rebuked Naim for interfering in state administration matters.

BN secretary-general Zambry Abd Kadir had announced the resignation on Nov 16, but the palace said the following day that it had yet to verify the authenticity of the letter, adding that the resignation was subject to the ruler’s consent.

Ismail continued as menteri besar on Nov 18 following an audience with Yang di-Pertuan Besar Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir the previous day.

Ahmad Zaharuddin Sani Ahmad Sabri
Ahmad Zaharuddin Sani Ahmad Sabri.

Zaharuddin said Naim’s claims warranted an explanation from Umno’s national leadership.

“If he was merely carrying out instructions, the leadership must explain who made the decisions and who should be held responsible.”

He said party leaders could not be allowed to share the credit when things go well only to shoulder the entire blame when problems arise.

Zaharuddin said the handling of the resignation also raised questions about whether political decisions had circumvented the proper constitutional process.

He said a party’s authority over its members did not replace the constitutional procedures governing a menteri besar’s appointment and departure from office.

“The palace is not the party secretary-general’s office, and royal consent is not merely a formality to legitimise political decisions that have already been announced,” he said.

The dispute with the palace stems from Ismail’s endorsement in September of a statement by the state’s newly sworn-in executive council affirming Tuanku Muhriz’s purported removal as ruler. The move saw the ruler revoke the appointments of all 10 exco members.

On Nov 18, Zambry urged that the process be allowed to take its course, saying: “I do not want to make any statements that might be misunderstood again.”

Zaharuddin said Ismail should be given space to explain his position, but describing the resignation as voluntary did not remove the leadership’s responsibility to explain its announcement.

“A statement by the president is no substitute for transparency,” he said.

He warned that perceived injustices arising from decisions made by Umno’s supreme council could lead to disappointment among the party’s grassroots leaders.

“What is more dangerous for Umno is not losing a menteri besar, but potentially losing the trust of leaders within the party,” he said.

1 comment:

  1. It is so obvioys that:
    1) Zahid and UMNO instigated the NS crisis
    2) The MB is certainly being fed to the lions
    3) Zahid's reprimand to Ismail's son Naim is irrational. As far as Naim and family members are concerned, since it impacts THEIR head of family, it IS a personal matter for them. Look at how Najib's daughter lamented so much about how her criminal father was being treated.

    I still hope the YDPB will:
    1) accept Ismail's resignation only directly from Ismail as per protocol
    2) will not reinstate the 10 ex-councillors
    3) will reject the new name recommended by UMNO to be MB

    ReplyDelete