Saturday, November 21, 2026

Perak water or bust: PBAPP says Penang has run out of options after 98pc EGM vote






Perak water or bust: PBAPP says Penang has run out of options after 98pc EGM vote



Penang Water Supply Corporation chief executive officer Datuk K. Pathmanathan says seawater desalination is too expensive to serve as the state’s water contingency plan. — Picture by Opalyn Mok


Summary

  • Penang’s RM24.6 billion plan to buy treated water from Perak won 98 per cent shareholder backing at an extraordinary general meeting today.
  • PBAPP chief executive Datuk K. Pathmanathan said Penang has no options left locally and described Perak as the best practical alternative to desalination.
  • The 40-year deal from 2032 to 2072 will supply at least 300 million litres a day from a new Perak plant, with safeguards for shortfalls.


First Published: Saturday, 21 Nov 2026 12:40 PM MYT


GEORGE TOWN, Nov 21 — Penang’s RM24.6 billion plan to buy treated water from Perak has won the backing of 98 per cent of shareholders in PBA Holdings Bhd (PBAHB), the parent company of the state water utility, at an extraordinary general meeting (EGM) here today.

Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP) chief executive officer Datuk K. Pathmanathan said the state’s Water Contingency Plan 2030 had run out of options within Penang, The Star reported.

“There is nothing left, so the only available opportunity is the Perak water source,” he was quoted as saying after the EGM.

He said PBAPP had compared the project with seawater desalination, which would cost substantially more and lead to a higher tariff.


“That is why we consider this project the best practical alternative for PBA,” he added.

Pathmanathan added that the minimum purchase of 300 million litres per day (MLD) was conservative, given the demand from Penang’s growing industrial sector and incoming investments.

“So we need more and more water,” he was quoted as saying, pointing to companies signing agreements and launching investments in Batu Kawan even as the EGM was under way.

Also present were PBAHB group chairman and Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow, State Secretary Datuk Jafri Abdul Jalil and PBAHB chief financial officer Mary Ann Harris.


The 40-year deal runs from 2032 to 2072 and covers a minimum of 300 MLD of treated water from a new 500 MLD plant in Perak, comprising RM8.4 billion in capacity charges and RM16.2 billion in supply charges.

Lim Guan Eng, the Bagan MP and former Penang chief minister, said on November 20 that Chow had ignored written objections from five independent PBAHB directors over the RM210 million PBAPP must pay Perak each year, even if no water or less than the contracted amount is supplied.


Lim said he supports sourcing water from Perak but objects to the financial terms, and claimed the full agreement had not been disclosed because of non-disclosure provisions.

Chow said on November 19 that the capacity charge was an “availability payment” that recovers the plant’s construction cost and is separate from payment for water actually supplied.

He said PBAPP pays the supply charge only for water it receives, and that safeguards in the agreement include compensation for shortfalls, a right to terminate and renegotiation if supply is suspended for more than three months.

1 comment:

  1. MADA has a daily update on its website on the storage levels of its principal dams -Pedu, Muda and Ahning. The bulk of Penang's iwater supply from the Muda river comes from these dams. In addition to PADI field irrigation.
    We are at the tail end of the rainy season in eastern Kedah, and the dams are at crisis levels.
    We can't depend only on the Muda river, especially with an increasingly belligerent Kedah State Government.

    ReplyDelete