Thursday, November 19, 2026

KLSCAH: The bigotry behind the outrage

 

KLSCAH: The bigotry behind the outrage

Tags

, , , , ,


[1] Federal Territories Minister Hannah Yeoh and Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim must be applauded for renewing the Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall’s lease for 99 years at a nominal land premium of RM1,000.[i] They did so knowing full well that anything which can be framed as a concession to the Chinese community would become ammunition for the bigots and racists who trade in communal grievance. In today’s political climate, that takes courage.

[2] The hall was gazetted as a heritage building in 2007. It has no commercial development value and runs an annual operating deficit of about RM400,000 because of an ageing structure, rising maintenance costs and the need to upgrade safety features. The government agreed that a 103-year-old civic institution should not be charged as if it were prime real estate.

[3] Some are now making a fuss about it. Umno Youth chief Dr Akmal Saleh took to Facebook to argue that the RM4.67 million premium could have helped public housing tenants in Kuala Lumpur. PAS Youth insisted that the land still had value even if it could not be developed. So far the leaders of both parties have said nothing.

[4] It is sad  that a little help extended to a cherished institution can become controversial. The majority community already receives the lion’s share of public spending. Budget 2026 set aside RM6 billion for MARA, Yayasan Peneraju and UiTM to expand Bumiputera education opportunities, and added 50 acres of Malay reserve land.[ii] It provided RM10 billion in government guarantees for Bumiputera entrepreneurs.[iii]It allocated RM2.6 billion to Islamic affairs, the largest such allocation in the nation’s history.[iv] All this on top of decades of preferential policies in education, business and the civil service.

[5] Yet, a relatively modest concession to a heritage build of deep symbolic importance to Chinese Malaysians generates opposition. They said little when billions were looted from 1MDB, and they still rally behind Najib Razak, a convicted criminal but they make a fuss over this. Let us be honest: this is not about governance, transparency or the urban poor. It is about who benefits. Had the hall been a Malay heritage site, not a word would have been said.

[6] Chinese Malaysians have contributed enormously to the development of this country. Their labour opened up the tin mines and built the towns. Their enterprise built much of the commercial backbone of the economy. Their taxes have funded generations of national development, including the very programmes that benefit Bumiputera Malaysians. Many would argue, with good reason, that their role has been critical to making Malaysia the nation it is today. The KLSCAH, a centre of Chinese civic life for more than a century, is part of that story. Supporting it is no favour; it is the least a grateful nation can do. I hope it endures for another hundred years; a reminder of the many hands that built this nation, and a rebuke to those who would deny us a shared future.

[8] The attempt by Umno and PAS to turn this into yet another race issue shows how petty, small-minded and mean-spirited they can be. As Yeoh observed, they play up such issues because she is a Chinese minister and a DAP minister.[v] This kind of racism must be called out, loudly and every single time. Every time it goes unchallenged, it becomes a little more acceptable, and the space for non-Malays in their own country grows a little smaller.

[Dennis Ignatius |Kuala Lumpur |18 November 2026]

4 comments:

  1. I'm going to be contrarian on this.

    The Kuala Lumpur and Selangor Chinese Assembly Hall’s core membership is actually Super Rich.
    The members, who are Chinese Business guilds , societies and associations of Malaysia's most concentrated business area collectively worth a Great many Billions of Ringgit.
    The KLSCAH has fallen into financial distress only because of the members unwillingness to contribute to this community asset.
    They apparently have "other priorities".
    They SHOULD step up first, instead of asking for a taxpayer discount.

    I am a member of the Penang Chinese Town Hall, the equivalent for Penang-Lang, and I have to say we are much more community-minded Up North, supporting the Chinese Community in so many ways.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. mfer, u r confusing KLSCAH with 马来西亚中华总商会(中总,ACCCIM)!

      Delete
    2. There is a large overlap in membership between ACCCIM and KLSCAH.
      The BIG difference is ACCCIM promotes the business and and commercial interests of it's membership, and is this very generously funded.

      While KLSCAH is a non-profit organisation supporting the wider Chinese community. And it is in financial distress.
      So what I pointed out stands - it's more affluent members -and there are plenty - should step up and contribute more to the organisation , first.
      Asking for a taxpayer discount instead falls into the trap of the likes of Akmal Saleh and Hadi.

      Delete
  2. Mongoliods like this binatang Akmal will only be happy if EVERYTHING is given to malays and muslims.

    There is no talking to such creatures because despite they praying 5 times a day, they simply do not understand what is fairness and justice.

    Maybe if muslims were required to pray the original 50 times a day asked by their Allah would some sense get through.

    ReplyDelete