Ramkarpal's excoriation of Mahathir is an indictment of Harapan's Phor-Laam-Par-ites

Malaysiakini:

Ramkarpal's excoriation of Mahathir is an indictment of Harapan

by S Thayaparan

"In politics - just as it is in religion - some people get an idea of the necessity of believing certain things, not so much from weight of evidence, out or in - but from mere mental and emotional set-ness: they intend believing - and that (is) all there is about it!"

- US poet Walt Whitman

Ramkarpal Singh’s plain-spoken scathing rebuke against the old maverick comes at a time when the Malay political establishment is at its most tumultuous. As someone who made a very public mea culpa about endorsing the old maverick, I understand where Ramkarpal is coming from.

I made it clear that enabling and supporting Dr Mahathir Mohamad, before the election (by people like me) and after (by bootlickers, sycophants, propagandists, and partisan rakyat) would lead to a big mess. The signs were glaringly obvious, but we did not pay attention.

The pro-Mahathir camp, as they do now, holds the threat of a “unified Malay resurgence” over the heads of middle-Malaysia as a warning if we do not support the political machinations of the old maverick. All this, I detailed in this public mea culpa:

“Worried about the far-right and agents of the fascist state coming into power? Well, this is what happens when a coalition breaks up because one man decides to screw everyone over in his coalition.

"This is the price we pay for compromising, enabling and justifying behaviour anathema to democratic practices, all because we wanted to remove Najib Abdul Razak.

"Worried about Najib coming back? Why? We have voted in kleptocrats for decades and when we had the chance for something new, the elected prime minister said that the manifesto was not worth the paper it was printed on and his erstwhile allies just buried their heads in the sand."

Think back to the time when, after the Sheraton Move, some sort of unity government was in play and folks still blamed Anwar Ibrahim "for being a power-hungry knave when all the old maverick wanted to do was steer the HMS Malaysia through choppy waters."

This is not the first time Ramkarpal has publicly admonished the old maverick. After the Kiwanis by-election fiasco in January this year, he said the old maverick should take responsibility for the loss and get a handle on the promised reforms, or else Harapan would become a one-term government.

He was also aghast that Mahathir said he would work with anybody – meaning Umno political operatives – which at the time, was supposedly verboten.

'Tuk, actually DAP is supposed to hold onto a "never with UMNO" policy, but we'll make an exception for you as you're our most beloved

well CuCu, whatever, I just don't give a shit for your DAP's policies

This got a rather queer dressing down from Ambiga Sreenevasan (above), who disagreed with “her friend” Ram: "What about the successes? What happened to collective responsibility? You cannot keep attacking your leader and then ask why Pakatan is weak. Could you do that in your party without consequences?"

The last part “could you do that in your party without consequences” was a pretty good jibe, because we all know how the DAP handles internal dissent.

Remember when the always pugnacious Ronnie Liu spoke out against the old maverick, calling him a paper tiger? Or whenever the "conscience" of the DAP, P Ramasamy, makes some very uncomfortable observations of how the DAP is on the wrong side – Mahathir's side – when it comes to hot button issues?

When someone like me questioned why the DAP was reaching out to the mufti of Perlis, I got a lecture from DAP about how we need to reach out in the then "New Malaysia".

Meanwhile, Liew Chin Tong says that the DAP needs to do everything to help young Syed Saddiq Abdul Rahman (below) to retain his seat (when he was with Bersatu), even though this was the young upstart who declared open season on the DAP, when party stalwarts dared criticise the then prime minister and Bersatu "Big Cheese", Mahathir.

Again and again and again - Aiseh, they don't malu, I malu for them




The irony, of course, is that Anwar, who has been there from the beginning, never got the bootlicking, big wet kisses, and "ride or die" support the old maverick got from the political elites of Harapan.

In his post, Ramkarpal lamented that he believed in the old maverick's reform agenda and now was incensed that he was lied to. Now, Ramkarpal is an intelligent man so I will take it to mean that, for the sake of political expediency and the desire to overthrow the Najib regime, he overlooked the sordid baggage Mahathir brought with him.

He is not the only one. I and many other Harapan supporters bit our tongues and played the same game.

Indeed, political operatives, who for years had portrayed the old maverick as an existential threat, forgot about all the scandals he brought with him and were smugly confident that nobody would allude to those scandals. Online vitriol by the faithful guaranteed that all these uncomfortable facts were buried and nobody, certainly not sceptics, could get a word in without being labelled as pro-Najib or BN sympathisers. Hence the kool-aid was truly dispensed.

Working alongside Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad to remove Datuk Seri Najib Razak as prime minister will backfire on Pakatan Rakyat (PR), a DAP lawmaker warned today.

Bukit Gelugor MP Ramkarpal Singh Deo stressed that Dr Mahathir’s desire to oust Najib was not fuelled by a need for a clean, transparent government, but only to “save Umno”.

“The question of working with Dr Mahathir is an unimaginable disaster waiting to happen.“There can be no doubt that Malaysia needs to be saved. While I agree that Najib ought to go, I cannot agree with the means by which Dr Mahathir proposes to do so,” Ramkarpal said in a statement here.

- 19 April 2015 (MM Online) 

“I want to clarify at this stage that it was interesting to see Tun Mahathir in support of Maria’s release when it was him that was instrumental in the cruel enforcement of the ISA.”

“Now I strongly urge the leaders of DAP to be very mindful when we choose our allies. Yes, there are no permanent friends, there are no permanent enemies, but there must be permanent principles. And when we choose our allies, we must be sure that their principles are genuinely in line with ours."

- Sangeeta Kaur Deo, 04 December 2016, DAP national conference, Shah Alam  

We were told to focus on the bigger issue, but the reality was that the bigger issue had always been the institutional corruption that led to squandered opportunities and a political elite who used government positions to enrich themselves and their cronies.

What Harapan’s short tenure demonstrated was that there were not enough voices in the administration to hold Mahathir accountable. Those who did were told, more often than not in a friendly manner, to shut up.





More importantly, there were many voices who coasted on their pre-election credibility among the Harapan base, who enabled Mahathir to dismiss the manifesto, dared Harapan to “fire” him, all the while undermining PKR to destabilise the position of his successor.

Going forward, no matter what the composition of Harapan is, no matter who Harapan chooses to work with, I hope that political operatives will, constructively and transparently, criticise their partners on issues that affect the voting public.

Remember folks, the whole point is not that Mahathir is some sort of great traitor, but rather Harapan political operatives enabled his behaviour - which led to its downfall.

S THAYAPARAN is Commander (Rtd) of the Royal Malaysian Navy. A retired barrister-at-law, he hopes young people will assume the mantle of leadership – if there is to be any hope for this country